It WAS Fanta Red cream. Henry Weinhart's is the closest tasting to it now, also top notch.
Nehi Blue Cream was pretty good, but it's now gone as well. The same with the Original New York Seltzer Vanilla Cream, long gone.
Virgil's Cream is great. Barrel Brothers is also real good. The Moxie Blue Cream is much better than the Moxie brown Cream (only fair). Frostie's Blue Cream is also good, and so is IBC.
A & W is just ok. Dad's Cream is only fair the one time I tried it, maybe I'll try it again. Barq's Red Cream had a little more strawberry than I like in it.
I've never had Mug's Cream. And I regret not trying Canfield's Swiss Cream. I need to try Dr. Brown's Cream again.
Life is too short to drink crummy sodas...