As far as a replacement beverage for Mt Dew, yes, I believe it flopped. As far as a volume seller I would say it was successful, from an initial marketing/sales standpoint, but not in longterm pull through.
Coke does what it normally does when it goes head to head with Pepsi. A great initial push to really get things going and then a quick fade away in hopes that the drink will sell on its "momentum". If Coke is ever really going to attack Mt Dew with a real contender it will have to accept the fact that it must do more than spend major ad dollars in 2 consecutive quarters to maintain any real serious competition to the Dew.
Although the marketing effort was grand it didn't hold up over the long haul. Coke had their marketing concepts drawn up for a short quick burst of sales volume and then moved on to something more exciting: COKE BLAK! LOL.
Whether you think can or think you can\'t, you\'re probably right!