How Everlane’s Founder Is Fashioning Success In CPG

Michael Preysman turned heads in 2011 when he launched pioneering DTC apparel brand Everlane. With his latest venture – Magna, a brand of sports wellness powders infused with magnesium – he has once again captured the attention of many, particularly those in the beverage industry.

In 2022, Michael stepped down as Everlane CEO and took a new role as the company’s executive chair and climate lead. After handing over the day-to-day responsibilities of running Everlane, whose 2023 revenues are pegged to be north of $200 million, Michael focused on Magna, which debuted last month.

Leading with the tagline “for those who play the long game,” Magna markets hydration powders that are made with three forms of magnesium along with electrolytes. The company, which developed the products in partnership with doctors and athletes, are promoted as providing greater focus, energy and recovery. 

Magna comes in four flavors – lemon lime, tea lemonade, watermelon lime, and peach mango – and is sold direct-to-consumer via its website, where a box of 30 sachets sells for $55 or $45 by subscription.

In this episode, Michael spoke about how his personal interest in magnesium spurred the development of Magna, how he leaned into his skill set to create the brand, lessons from building Everlane that he is applying to the new company and the surprises and challenges that have come during his second stint at entrepreneurship.

Show notes:

Michael and Taste Radio editor Ray Latif chat about their respective philosophies on facial hair, whether the entrepreneur wears his own brand and why 1/11/11 is an important day in his life. Michael also discusses the origins of Magna and why he chose to create a beverage powder versus an RTD, creating authentic relationships with customers, his perspective on differentiation for both Everlane and Magna and why the latter’s packaging draws inspiration from a cigarette brand. He also talks about content creation and the value of people in advertising, how he thinks about and implements a customer service strategy, why co-packing is trickier than he anticipated and how to identify and work with mentors.

Brands in this episode: Magna

Transcript

Note: Transcripts are automatically generated and may contain inaccuracies and spelling errors.

Speaker 1 [00:04] Hey folks, it's Ray with Taste Radio. Right now I'm honored to be sitting down with Michael Praiseman, the founder of Everlane and Magna. Michael, great to see you.

Speaker 2 [00:13] Great to see you too. Thanks for having me on a, on a, uh, Tuesday

Speaker 1 [00:16] morning. You know, I always have a beard. I haven't, uh, shaved to the skin since 2011. I expected to see you with a beard too cause your LinkedIn profile has you as one, has you as having one. And when did you start shaving?

Speaker 2 [00:26] Well, If you work in apparel for 10 years, your hair automatically turns gray, at least the beard part. So if I were to grow this all out, I'm 39, but I would look a solid 59, and so I decided to keep it trim. And then actually just the other day I was with a friend at Gold's gym in Venice, and he took a picture with me, and he's 50, and my, my parents said, wow, he looks younger than you. And so I started shaving a little bit more.

Speaker 1 [00:58] OK, uh, as soon as your parents start telling you you're old, I, I guess that can be a problem for you, but you 39, 39 is absolutely not old. You look quite youthful. You survived 10+ years of the apparel business, actually, what is it now, 14 years if you, uh, since Everlane was launched.

Speaker 2 [01:13] It was, you know, funniest story. I didn't realize until actually just a couple of months ago that we launched on 11-1-11, so 11111. OK, November 1st, 2011.

Speaker 1 [01:26] One would think that's probably a lucky number to launch,

Speaker 2 [01:29] I guess it was pretty lucky, yeah, we had a good run. We have a good run,

Speaker 1 [01:32] exactly. You still have a good run. Uh, if I had an apparel brand, if I had a fashion brand, I expected I'd be wearing my clothes all the time. Do you always wear Everlane?

Speaker 2 [01:41] Thank thankfully I'm wearing Everlane right now, yeah.

Speaker 1 [01:44] Thankfully, so, not exactly,

Speaker 2 [01:46] yes, you gotta, you gotta test. You gotta, you gotta try the competition, right? If you're in the beverage industry, you don't just drink your own beverage, uh, every day. You gotta, you, you gotta try what else is it out there and always be comparing and testing the competition.

Speaker 1 [01:58] That's a very good point. So Michael, uh, I am so excited, uh, that you are now in the beverage industry. Uh, it's very exciting. Uh, it'll drive you crazy and hopefully there'll be some good rewards at the end. Um, Magna is a really interesting brand. Tell us about the origins of Magna and how long you've been working on it.

Speaker 2 [02:20] Yeah, I'm excited to be in the industry as well. It's, I was on a walk about 2 years ago when I stepped out of the CEO's seat with a friend over at one of the famed groups, uh, investor groups, EMG Capital and VMG Partners, and he said, Man, if you made it through. The apparel industry and we are able to build something so successfully. I'm excited to see what you do in our industry, which is the world of wellness, um, and of course I picked the more complicated one in the world of beverage but still excited to be in it because um it's just a totally different lens and different way of building. The, the move to this industry really started because I, after Apparel, um, decided that what interests me and what has always interested me is the intersection of cultural conversations and building products people love, and cultural conversation has really shifted away from material goods to uh how do you feel physical. Um, and longevity and life, and that's really a post-COVID mentality of people start to look inwards and say, what, how am I living my life and is it worth it? Um, and how do I live longer, healthier, happier, and that was a big shift that I saw happening. Um, and within that what we see a big opportunity is to build at this intersection of nutrition and wellness as well as building emotional brands. So many of the brands built in that world of nutrition, wellness and beverage, although beverage. RTD can be a bit better um are just very clinical brands and so we started playing around with what is a way to both inspire people to move their bodies more um because if you want to be on a health journey, you want to live till you are 80, you want to live till you are 100, number one thing you can do. I move your body more. You move your body more, you sleep better, you live longer. The muscle that you have will allow you to stay mobile and active into your old, old age. And granted, I'm only 39, but I think we all start to think about how do we live not just to make it to 80, but make it to 80 and thriving. Um, and so that was, that was one piece of it is let's build a brand that inspires the movement and then the other piece of it was really geared on how do we create a product that helps with that. And the second most uh largest deficiency in the uh human nutrition is magnesium and so we thought how do we build around magnesium into a product that can uh really become enjoyable and become part of the diet and nutrition everyday and so with that we we bor uh Magna was born and it took us about I do not know a year. Uh, to bring it to life, um, in full across all the design, products, development, and flavor, and if you, if you haven't tasted it, the flavor is just really killer. We spend a lot of time on flavor because at the end of the day, that's what, that's what matters, um, that's what keeps people coming back.

Speaker 1 [05:19] For sure. Taste is king, always has been, always will be, but magnesium is a very trendy ingredient. It is something that people are becoming much more educated about, um, and you talked about. Coming out with a powder versus an RTD. Was there a time when you thought you could launch a liquid beverage, or, uh, is that in the, is that in the pipeline?

Speaker 2 [05:43] It's not in the pipeline, and no, I have always known what my core skill set is and when building any brand or product or business, I think leaning into what your skill set is is really critical and reinventing the wheel is, it is possible but it is not for the faint of heart. So I know D2C. I know digital really well, um, and so we thought about what is the platform that allows us to build digitally first. Retail will of course be a part of it in a big way, um, and we have uh great advisors and great relationships there that we are building, um, but it's not the out of the gate, um, solution because we want to win on digital first.

Speaker 1 [06:22] Yeah, that's a good segue to my next question, which is about D2C. Are there learnings that you can take from Everlane and apply them to Magna, or are they two completely different? Categories, product types.

Speaker 2 [06:37] They are in some ways infrastructure wise, very similar, uh, in branding very similar but in ways that you have to get in front of the customer completely different. So pulling that apart, it is so much easier to start a brand today, which is why there is so much more competition, why, you know, creators can launch brands, it is why if you wanted to launch a brand tomorrow, I think I might be drinking your beverage, um, and you could do it very successfully, um, but Uh, and that is, you know, Shopify, Clavio, all the different stacks on digital that you can go, then the integration with retail, everything is out there, lots of great readings. Then it comes to the branding. There's a lot to learn from Everlane. We really leaned into the idea of radical transparency and ideology that was borrowing from the food industry at the time because it was about how to bring transparency to the industry. Um, and that is what the food industry had done through sourcing, uh, through local organic, and we brought that mentality to apparel. What we have with Magna is a different ideology that sits around what I was just talking about, around the longevity we call play the long game, and it's a, I would say post. COVID post- Nike ideology where everything was win at all costs, just do it, um, and is it in you to a live for it, don't die for it, that we're here to play the long game that we got to improve each and every day, but it's not about being the best, it's about being your best. And that is a really critical part of the brand that we are building out. um, but then the way you get in front of customers, man, that is so different. I, I was surprised because in our world we launch new product every week, sometimes multiple times a week, and the product was the content because you could say hey check out this new sweater, check out this new shirt. In the world of beverage. In the world of a lot of CPG, you are not introducing new product every week, every month. Sometimes if you are, you know, uh, Coca-Cola, you do not even introduce new product every year and so the way you are staying top of mind is through content and connection. It is about building relationships with people um and fostering those relationships and at the same time building content that resonates and engages the consumer and that is a very different strategy of how to do it even though at the end we needed to do that in apparel, it was always done through new product innovation and that is very different here.

Speaker 1 [09:10] And you built great relationships with your consumers at Everlane, uh, and, and I think that building relationships, a deep relationship with your customers is such a critical part of retention, getting them to come back to your website, getting them to tell their friends about your products, but it's not as easy as it sounds. How do you build a relationship such that the customer stays with you for a long period of time, if not the lifetime of your brand?

Speaker 2 [09:40] It is a great question. I think ultimately, first and foremost is you have to have great product that people love and I have seen candidly with Everlane we have had periods where we have had OK product when we launched and the brand carried all the weight. Then we had great product and we had really high engagement. The number of people that said Uh, they would be devastated if the brand did not exist tomorrow, which is a measure of sort of brand love was very high. And then, uh, we had that wane during COVID and now it is coming back, but it is sort of the loyalty really sticks starts with product and it ends with Individual connections and in between there is that content and conversation and community that you can build. So, uh, that content, community and connection are sort of to me the three pillars of it. Um, content gets you out there, people go, oh, that is a brand I can associate with. I like that. Then community allows you to foster the conversation amongst the group and connection is that 1 to 1 and I think of it right now when we are starting, it is hard to foster community and content all out of the gate, so we are really focused on connection, one on one individual block, block by block. How do we build individual relationships where they know who I am and they know who the rest of the team is and that is the work we are doing right now. Within that then what you will see us doing next is how do we build community and you will see us show up in Los Angeles in a big way in San Francisco um and then we will shift to new communities within New York, DC, etc. um so community will be a big part of it and then you will layer on the content after that.

Speaker 1 [11:18] I think because Everlane came out of the gate with this radically different approach to apparel and fashion, it's helped people understand that this brand is different, and there was an authentic story behind that marketing with that positioning. Can you do the same, or is there a similar kind of story you can tell with Magna in that this is a product that is very differentiated from other powders or other uh products that use magnesium as their key ingredient.

Speaker 2 [11:47] So, it's interesting because what you just said is Everlane came out as a different brand, but the product actually was entirely generic. We started with a t-shirt. It was about as basic as you can get. And then we were in sweaters and sweatshirts and Oxford. Everything was basic to the bone. And yet we were able to build differentiation here. The product is actually More differentiated than what is out there relative to the market, but there are way more upstarts and so the brand feels a little bit like it has to do the work to feel more unique. What is going to resonate long term is this content piece, um, and that is going to take time. It is not going to be like the days of Everlane where you can just come out of the gate. With something that feels completely different because I am sure you know it more than anyone. It is a much busier world today. You go onto the shelves and you see how many different New beverages there are in RTD every month is just insane. You go to Erwan and it's a wall full of Beverages and then even if you look at lollipop, there's, I think it's lollipop has 17 different flavors. I mean they're trying to claim shelf space wherever they go, so it is very fierce and the moats that exist in this industry are shallower and shallower.

Speaker 1 [13:09] Well, Erawan is an amazing place to shop, and I've spoken with their COOO here on Taste Radio about their strategy, their selection, particularly of beverages, and he made it clear, you know, Erawan is a place for discovery. People want to go there and find different things, and they're changing up their sets almost every 2 weeks. And a lot of what people will see is based on the packaging, obviously, the packaging and the branding. And You, a magnet that is, have great packaging. Your branding is fantastic. It stands out. It's, um, that, that yellow and black color palette just really looks different than a lot of things I've seen in the past. How did you think about going about package design? What were the most essential elements of that design?

Speaker 2 [14:00] Yeah, it's interesting, you know, obviously so much of building a brand is the aesthetic and, and, and feel of the people who build it, um, and when people think of Everlane, they think of minimalist and white and gray, um, as the original sort of base, but I've always sort of believed in this very minimal undertone with pops of color, um, to grab attention. And so in that way, magna sits as the pop of color in someone's life, where if I look back at your shelf, shelves behind you, that yellow would really pop on the shelves behind you and stand out to your point. And so we wanted something that felt quite electric, um, that felt inspiring and motivating, but also stood out, um, and so color was a huge role in that and, and there is a lot more to the color palette than just the yellow, um, we have used a little bit of it, but there is this crazy purple, um, and really, uh, vibrant green as well, um, so those will all come to life. And from a logo perspective, I mean the logo and the colors where we invested quite a bit, um there is also a mark that is based off of um Uh, the magnesium molecule, and so you'll see quite a bit come to light from that perspective. The Magna logo itself is something that felt almost game-like, bold, heavy, and could stand on its own on a sheet, but also stand on top of a photo and feel very retro at the same time. And so that was a lot of what we played with was how do we both play in the world of nostalgia, which is so critical to sport and to beverage as well as play into modernity um and get something that pops forward. Um, from a packaging perspective, it was similar, um, and we were, while it is not healthy for you, we very much always love the Marlboro box, um, and just how iconic it was, and so there was definitely that reference that we pulled from with that Marlboro at the top and just that that very killer vibrancy of the package, so we played with that as well. We tried to design the box originally like the Marlboro box but still haven't landed the plane on that. We'll, we'll get there eventually.

Speaker 1 [16:06] Well, for someone who has a creative streak as much as you do, were you relying, uh, on a branding agency, on a package design agency, as much as some other entrepreneurs do, or were you leading the, the. Uh, the strategy when it came to designing the package.

Speaker 2 [16:22] Strategically we did everything internally. Um, we definitely, we work with a whole host of freelancers and work with different partners, um, and, uh, and firms to help us out, so we have got probably 2 or 3 different firms in the world of creative has changed so much in the sense that 1015 years ago, there were not the tools for creatives to be able to connect with companies directly, um, and have a beautiful site, have an Instagram, and have a network of people that introduced them and so over the past 10 years, what I have seen is that so many creatives want to be freelance and some of the best creatives have just a two-person shop. Um, the original Everlane logo was actually done by a husband and wife team. Um, that worked in Brooklyn that still I consider some of the best designers out there, um, and while we did not work with them here, it is just very similar to find these groups of one or two folks that work really well with you and that you then end up maybe retaining or not, um, to continue to work together.

Speaker 1 [17:25] Going back to telling the content story or telling the story about Magna through content. You know, with, with Everlane, the clothes always looked better on someone, on a model. With Magna, I wonder, does the marketing, does the um Advertising of the brand, for lack of a better word, work better in your opinion with people, or can it stand out on its own?

Speaker 2 [17:53] It's a great question. Out of the gate, what we, one of our core truths is that people love the branding and the packaging. We have gotten that consistently, so that is great. The piece about it that I do believe is I believe people matter um and so we have not figured that out yet, but we will be investing quite a bit into making sure that we can get the um Getting that come to come to life, um, and that people will be a very core part when we go back to content community connection. The middle of that that connects everything is people.

Speaker 1 [18:29] Well, you already have a great team of people of endorsers, um, I don't know if they're, uh, equity partners in the brand or not, but, um, people like Christian, uh, Press from Angel City FC, um, and Jackie Bunton, uh, who's, I believe, an MMA fighter, um. Yeah, these are folks who may not be household names but are up and coming athletes who seem to have an authentic connection to the brand. Talk about that ambassador strategy or that athlete partner strategy when coming out of the gate and why it's so important for Magna.

Speaker 2 [19:11] Yeah, I mean, Jackie's a kickboxer, Kristen, who's over at um uh AFC, you know, for us, what we wanted to find is, and, and even Barron, who's um a surfer who's, um, um, you know, um, up in Hawaii, and what we wanted to find was these individual sports that people can tap into. You know, you and I tomorrow can go and kickbox. Are we going to be Jackie? No way. Um, but at least there is an entry point into those sports, and they are very much sports that are cross-functional where you have to have so much endurance and you have to have strength and you have to also, you can with biking, you can go bike 5 miles or you can go bike 600 miles. You can run. For a couple of miles or you can go run an ultra. I mean we are not going to run an ultra but um many people do, um, and so there is this beauty of these sports that are sports you can do your entire life and you can start small and go big and I think obviously nothing captures that more uh than, um, uh. Someone winning an Olympic gold medal in cycling that had just started 7 years ago and all and then, you know, was a was in finance and then dropped out and she, she did an amazing job and won the Olympic gold yesterday. So I, I, I love stories like that

Speaker 1 [20:34] for sure, for sure. I also love stories. Clearly I love telling stories about entrepreneurship and Uh, folks who have, who have quote unquote made it. And you know, you having been an entrepreneur since 2011 with Everlane and now back in the game, so to speak with Magna. Is it harder now? I mean, is it, do you feel like you're in a better place? Do you feel like you're kind of in the same place as you were, you were in 2011?

Speaker 2 [21:02] It's much calmer the second time around, which is good and bad, um, but the first time around there's no playbook, and I look back at it. I spent some time looking back, I spent a few hours at all of the original work we did the first month, and it was wild because there was no program for email marketing. There was no, there were no tools for email marketing. There were, uh, we built our own shopping platform because Shopify was not really a thing. Stripe did not really exist and so there were so many ways that we had to do this that were completely Uh, unwritten rules, and in that way the rules are much more written, but by the rules being written, it means there's more competition because when the rules are written, other people can follow them. And so there's just, it's a totally different type of game to play now where it's the same as Olympics or any sport, world records are broken. Every year because the level of competition is rising, the level of knowledge in how you play the game rises, and it makes the sport stronger and more competitive, and that's true of entrepreneurship. The sport of entrepreneurship is more competitive and stronger. And, and what's even more interesting is that in a post. venture world where people were raising tons of money for anything, you really have to focus down to the scent on the unit economics um and that is much more critical and that is actually very similar to the way it was when I built Everlane, it is just the world changed for a bit and now it is back to that. So that is good to see because I think that discipline is critical and helpful.

Speaker 1 [22:40] I think unit economics are extremely important. I also think going back to this notion of a great relationship with your customers, with your consumers is so important as well, and customer service is a key part of that. Having a direct to consumer business with Everlane, I gotta think you learned quite a bit about how to interact with customers to keep them happy. And you know, to keep that relationship going even if something goes wrong, how do you carry that into that great customer service? How do you carry that into Magna?

Speaker 2 [23:12] Yeah, it is interesting because in apparel there is a lot more touch points of customer satisfaction or dissatisfaction moreover, because the product can come, it does not meet your expectations because what you saw and what you got look different, feel different, most importantly fit different and by the way, it might not look the same as new as it does on a model on the screen and so there was always a Opportunity to engage with the customer on that level and 01 more, how do I style this? So tons of ways to address that with our product, I am still looking for a bit of that because the connection point is the product is so much more consistent. And clear and it has less variables which makes it all easier but at the same time what what was actually interesting is that by having all those other variables in apparel you had more touch points into the consumer to create a narrative and a story and a connection point. It's like um Uh, you know, a drink of water is less interesting than a 10 course meal at a restaurant. So how we find ways to engage with the customer is really critical and build um connection points and it is still early days on that and have work to do, but the more we can integrate into their life and build an ambassador network, the better.

Speaker 1 [24:34] You know, Michael, I talked to a lot of entrepreneurs, both early stage and established, and you're both. You're an established entrepreneur with Everlane. You're an early stage entrepreneur with Magna. And the folks that I talked to who are 2 weeks in, 1 month in, in the beverage industry really don't have any idea what they're in for, and sometimes that's a good thing. I hear naivete is, is, uh, is something that helps entrepreneurs, and they always say, I never would have done this if I had known how hard this is going to be. But you know, for you, having the perspective of, having built Everlane. You know, what's been most surprising to you as an entrepreneur in the beverage industry? You know, what's been hardest for you? What's something that um you didn't expect once you entered this business?

Speaker 2 [25:19] Two realities have been surprising. The first is on the background, I was We worked with 20 different factories at Everlane and more at certain points. And You would think Manufacturing for apparel is complex, but it was in the end we had very few issues, um, even though we would source fabric, buttons, zippers, all kinds of accouterments, we had fit issues, we had to stretch the, we had to stretch the fit across, you know, extra small to double XL or 00 to 20, and yet we had very few issues. With our product, there has just been a ton of complexity in terms of the coal man and getting that right. And we are working through it and building a strong partnership, but I was surprised at how challenging that was because in apparel people work 24/7 and And things work out generally well on the manufacturing side. So that was definitely one surprise. The other reality that was a surprise was Even though it's the 2nd time and I, you know, I should know better, you always want to believe you have lightning in a bottle. Oh, if you build it, they will come and I am the #1 believer in having a distribution strategy out of the gate and knowing what your distribution strategy is, but it was surprising how much work. It took and how much noisier the market is today than it was probably even 5 years ago, but definitely 10+ years ago. And I'm all up for the challenge just like any other moment you say, oh shit, and then you rally the team and everybody says, let's do this. And so it's been, um, I think quite bonding and every day we're seeing actually pretty incredible improvements in growth, so not just week over week but day over day, which is awesome.

Speaker 1 [27:32] When you talk about the team, are they folks that have experience in this industry, or are they folks that you distrust?

Speaker 2 [27:39] Uh, they are on the creative and marketing side. It is a whole host of people from the days of Everlane, some freelance, some full time. And then on the operations, it's, you know, it's a very small team. There's full time, we, we're keeping it very below sub 10. Um, I believe in this new model which is can you build businesses to, you know, uh, 9 digits with a low double digit team. Um, what does that take? How do you do it? And, um, in that way, yeah, the, the other part of it is operationally driven, um, and those are folks from the industry.

Speaker 1 [28:15] You know, I always advocate for Mentors in this industry or I always advocate that people have mentors in this industry because it can be lonely, it can be tough, you can be misled, and having people who know the business or at least can listen is so important. But how do you, how do you find good mentors? How do you find people that can give you good advice?

Speaker 2 [28:45] That's through a lot, you know, fortunately, I think in the, in the position of being a founder and a CEO and having um Uh, you build a lot of camaraderie, so I, I have the fortune of in the past having, you know, a wonderful mentor in the apparel world, Betsy McLaughlin, who built, um, Uh, Hot Topic and then went on to sit on a number of boards and she's been a great mentor and in this case, you know, a good friend, um, Eric Ryan, um, who's been really helpful and thoughtful in terms of how to build this out, he's built out Ollie Welly method all at Target, so he's quite versed in the space and then, you know, it goes back to one of the first people I ever met on my founder journey was the uh someone who was the president of Red Bull North America for 10 years, so. Um, I take the time to meet with any CEO founder that I can and, and try to do likewise for others, um, because I agree um that shared knowledge goes a long way.

Speaker 1 [29:41] Oh, you gotta be a little careful about that because people are going to hear this and hit you up on LinkedIn all the time.

Speaker 2 [29:48] I don't really check LinkedIn, so they'll have to find another way in. Oh,

Speaker 1 [29:51] you always, you rarely check LinkedIn. Yeah,

Speaker 2 [29:53] I rarely do, you know, it's like it's so noisy. So if they find another way in, great.

Speaker 1 [29:59] Fair enough, fair enough. Well, I think listening to this interview has been hugely helpful for some folks. Michael, it's been such an honor speaking with you. Thank you so much for taking the time and uh good luck going forward with Magna.

Speaker 2 [30:10] Thank you very much and likewise, and I hope you have a great day and huge fan and thanks for doing this.

Speaker 1 [30:16] Appreciate you saying that. Thanks again.

Related Videos