Category Close-Up: Plant-Based Meats - Expert Analysis

 

NOSH CATEGORY CLOSE UP PRESENTED BY:

 

Available exclusively to BevNET and NOSH subscribers, this week readers are invited to watch the first NOSH installment of our new Category Close-Up show, which features our Expert Panel and Product Showcase videos.

During the Expert Panel part of Category Close-Up, we’ll bring together a group of experts from across the industry to take a closer look into the industry dynamics shaping major food and beverage categories. With the help of top analysts, investors, buyers and retail brands leaders, we’ll delve into the trends, consumer behaviors, investment activity and retail movements that are driving categories forward and impacting the brands within them.

To kick off the series on NOSH, Editor Carol Ortenberg will be joined by a panel to examine the plant-based protein space — a rapidly growing category that has kept brands, consumers and retailers across channels on their toes. Our panel will examine how the category, including both refrigerated and frozen products, is positioned as supermarkets welcome a new set of sustainable protein offerings that go beyond the meat and fish products that have been in stores for decades.

NOSH’s guests include:

Jaime Athos, President and CEO, Tofurky; Melissa Abbott, VP Retainer Services, The Hartman Group, Lee Robinson, Director of Refrigerated Grocery and Beverage, Whole Foods Market; Melissa Facchina, General Partner & Co-Founder, Siddhi Capital and CEO and Founder, Siddhi Ops; T.K. Pillan, Exec Chairman & Co-Founder, Veggie Grill and Partner & Co-Founder, PowerPlant Ventures

Following each Expert Panel, the next day, we’ll shift to the brands’ perspective, hearing directly from the companies that are actively creating and responding to these market shifts during our Product Showcase. During our first episode, which is set to air Wednesday, we’ll interview a range of plant-based protein leaders, who will discuss both strategy and new product innovation.

Transcript

Note: Transcripts are automatically generated and may contain inaccuracies and spelling errors.

Carol Ortenberg [00:07] Hi everyone, I'm Carol, the editor of Nosh, and welcome to the next show in our new category close-up series. In this show, we bring together a group of experts. From across the industry to take a closer look into the dynamics shaping major food and beverage categories, with the help of top analysts, investors, buyers, and retail brand leaders, we'll delve into the trends, consumer behaviors, investment activity, and retail movements that are driving categories forward and impacting the brands within them. To kick off the first show in the series covering the food space, we'll be taking a look at a rapidly growing category that has kept brands, consumers, and retailers across channels on their toes, and that's plant-based protein. Our panel will examine how the category, including both refrigerated and frozen products, is positioned as supermarket. Markets welcome a new set of sustainable protein offerings that go beyond the meat and fish products that have been in stores for decades. Following each episode of Category Close Up, we'll shift to the brand's perspective, hearing directly from the companies that are actively creating and responding to these market shifts during our product showcase. In our first episode, which will air tomorrow, we'll interview a range of plant protein leaders who will discuss both strategy and new product innovation. But for now, I would like to introduce our guest for this episode. First up, we have T.K. Pillan, the executive chairman and co-founder of Fast casual, plant-based restaurant chain Veggie Grill. TK is also a partner and co-founder at PowerPlant Ventures, which is a growth equity fund investing in emerging consumer food, beverage, and food service companies. Next, we have Jaime Athos, the president and CEO of Tofurky, a plant-based protein brand that is celebrating its 40th anniversary this year, and has, over time, expanded from its namesake dish to a wide range of meat alternatives. We also have Melissa Facchina, who is the general partner and co-founder at Siddhi Capital, which has invested in the likes of plant-based brands including Good Catch, No Evil, and Mou. She's also the CEO and founder of Siddhi Ops, an outsourced operations firm that has helped numerous plant-based companies solve their manufacturing and production issues. Next, Lee Robinson is the director of refrigerated grocery and beverage for Whole Foods Market. Lee cultivates a rapidly expanding set of plant-based proteins for a growing consumer base who are increasingly more aware of and interested in purchasing plant-based protein alternatives. Finally, Melissa Abbott is the vice president of retainer services at the Hartman Group, a research consulting firm that examines consumer motivations, culture, and trends for leading food and beverage brands. I'd also like to mention our sponsor, Top Health Ingredients. The ideal plant-based meat alternative starts with the perfect combination of plant-based ingredients. It's about fusing taste, texture, and functionality to foster flawless imitation. For over a decade, Top Health Ingredients has provided its customers a market edge by supplying best in class novel ingredient solutions that have helped several of the food industry's most innovative companies launch award-winning meat analogs. Whether you're creating a new plant-based meat or seafood alternative, or simply evolving your product portfolio to serve a more plant-based future, Top Health can help. Visit their website at www.thealth ingredients.com to view and request samples of their industry leading plant proteins and more. Finally, before we begin, I wanna talk about the recent months. The COVID-19 pandemic drove hordes of shoppers to retailers, both online and in brick and mortar, unable to always find exactly the products they wanted and with concerns of a potential meat short. Many shoppers turn to plant-based protein alternatives. Still, even with the unplanned spike in sales, consumer awareness has been on the rise, with even mainstream consumers being exposed to new model plant burgers everywhere from Burger King to their local bodega. So I'd like to start here and talk about this massive shift that we've seen in the industry. Jaime, Tofurky has been around for decades. How has the image of vegan meat or plant-based meat shifted, and how has the consumer shifted as well?

Speaker 2 [04:44] Uh, well, it's shifted a lot, as you kind of alluded to. I'd even roll back to prior to Tofurky to start that history. Um, that sort of in that era of plant-based meats, um, consumers were seeking out non-animal solutions for religious reasons, usually. Seventh Day Adventists and otherwise and so you can imagine that was a group that's willing to, for lack of a better word, suffer to not eat animals, so they had low expectations in terms of the similarity to the real animal meats, and some of those religious traditions actually went out of their way to avoid having. Too much flavor, too much stimulation in their diet too. So you can imagine that was a really bland era in plant-based meats. Roll forward a bit and I'd kind of identify another era which is the health food era. And health food is not fun and it's also not all that tasty and obviously it's really primary motivation is to be nutritious and sort of, sort of in the post-health food or the tail end of the health food era is sort of what Tofurky came out of. Tofurky was Branford and whimsical and fun and not. Not serious like health food, but also started to kind of bring in that flavor forward kind of element to products and then that almost sort of predicted what we see today, which is a real aggressive step toward similarity. Now, you know, the mainstreaming of plant-based meats means that people who are motivated not by religion, not by health concern, but by all kinds of things started to gravitate toward plant-based meats. And so now, The mandate for us is to make those things as similar as possible, and that's what, you know, that's, I think, a big part of what we're seeing right now. The products that we see today are able to mimic not just the form and function and flavor of meats to a higher degree than we've ever seen, but they're also able to perform in the kitchen environment, sometimes in fast food kitchen environments too. And so that that kind of flexibility and the familiarity of kind of function is really important as well. So it's a, it's, it's really, you know, come a long way, but that's not to say that there aren't consumers that still have their own kind of niche interests, and they don't all want that kind of experience. But certainly the mainstream consumer, they're crossing over, they're primarily meat consumers, and they're crossing over from meat, and they want to find familiarity.

Carol Ortenberg [07:12] Melissa, the Hartman Group has done numerous studies surveying consumer preferences over the years. How have you seen consumer awareness and adoption of this category change as Jaime kind of referenced?

Speaker 3 [07:25] Well, it's been really fascinating over the past 5 to 7 years, um, because what we found is that the more health and sustainability oriented consumer was the one really driving this interest in plant-based as well as ethical animal consumption, but this notion of plant-based has really in our, our more recent study about uh consumption and purchase of plants. Based products, uh, it's really we were surprised to find that it, it is quite health driven. We thought it was going to be more about sustainability because that's more of the aspiration that consumers tend to talk about, but it is, it is driven by health motivations first and foremost, um, and it is the younger consumer who's really the one who's purchasing them, the millennials and the Gen X and the Gen Z. Um, and it's, if it doesn't deliver on taste, that is the most, uh, compelling aspect that they will, will steer them away from plant-based proteins and other plant-based products.

Carol Ortenberg [08:23] One thing we've certainly seen the rise of is star power when it comes to certain brands. Melissa, at Siddhi Ops and Capital, you've advised a number of plant-based brands. How important is having both a product that tastes good, as Melissa said, as well as, you know, that brand power and that brand recognition? How do those two go hand in hand?

Speaker 4 [08:46] Uh, I think, uh, both are required, and I would add a third bucket to that which is scalability. Uh, so if a consumer is not intimidated by the product, the it's a flavor profile that's of interest to them, uh, there's a brand that they can get behind either from a social mission, an environmental mission, an animal rights mission, uh, or quite frankly, some people, uh, wanna get behind it. Or just a really great brand, uh, and ethos, uh, positioning. I think if you couple both of those things with mass scale manufacturing potential, that's when you have the opportunity to blend them all, uh, and get real, uh, opportunity for growth and change in the industry. So, so I would say they're all equally important.

Carol Ortenberg [09:38] Jaime, you've had to evolve the Tofurky brand over the last couple of years, uh, undergoing a rebrand, adding in some cartoon characters and some more fun messaging. Did you feel that brand was really important to the consumer, and so that's why you needed to undertake this?

Speaker 2 [09:57] I think that Tofurky, the changes that you've just described in Tofurky's kind of presentation to the public came about because the, the, the Tofurky consumer has shifted, you know, we were speaking to an audience that really knew us well. We have always had a very intimate connection to our consumers, but as more and more mainstream consumers cross over and start dabbling in the plant-based space, they don't all know us well. So we had to be more proactive about both understanding of our own selves like who we were, but also more directly and confidently projecting that image to our consumers. We can't just rely on them knowing us and having, you know, grown up with our Tofurky products and their holiday traditions or whatever. A lot of these folks have never really tried any plant-based products, and so we needed to kind of be more. A more forward with telling people who we were.

Carol Ortenberg [10:53] I think, uh, Jaime brings up a great point about drawing in new consumers. Lee, when thinking about brand recognition, how vital is it for a brand to have that persona and that brand recognition in order to first get onto retailers' shelves, and then to, you know, get consumers to come over to that set and purchase their products.

Speaker 5 [11:15] Yeah, that's a great question, Carol. I actually think that, yes, it's important, but as we've mentioned already, and, and inevitably this comes up, flavor is king. And so if there are ways to get those consumers to sample the product, to try it, to hear about it through word of mouth, the brand recognition is important, but I would say it's not necessarily as important in that segment as maybe others. There's a strong appetite, sorry, pun not intended, had to do it. There's a strong appetite though for the substitution or how to eat meat in moderation by maybe taking down the overall consumption with some of these products, so you'll see it end up in mixed baskets. That trial is um really driven by that desire to just kind of go for it. So I think the brand recognition actually helps once they get Into the category, they try new products, they might try Tofurky products and then wander over to the frozen aisle and say, oh hey, I like Tofurky, I'm gonna grab this other product they make or whatever. And so that's a really great bridge over to other segments. But I think for intro into the category, um, it's not necessarily something that's automatically a prerequisite.

Carol Ortenberg [12:31] Have you all found how consumers initially shop that set? Are they going over with an eating occasion in mind? Uh, are they looking for, hey, I need a patty, or I need a nugget, or are they just kind of browsing and seeing what attracts their attention?

Speaker 5 [12:48] Yeah, it really, it depends on which customer segment we're talking about. Ah, to Jamie's point, there's a, a very loyal customer that has been shopping that set for a long time. They probably pick up a couple packs of firm tofu every week, and a few others, and they just know they'll find a use for it, whether they have a recipe in mind or not. It's a staple in their fridge. But other demographics are coming in saying, hey, I've heard about this, I'm going to give it a shot, or maybe I have a cookout coming up, and I think it'd be fun to bring this along as a discussion point. So there are different entry points now, and I think a lot of that, um, depending on what the segment is, could actually have to do with what the entry category was that they came into. And certainly we've seen some categories drive that forward. Maybe it's fluid milk, maybe it's yogurt, so if they've come into plant-based from a different angle, then the crossover and the shopping occasion can change based on that.

Speaker 3 [13:49] I can speak to that as well, Carol, um, and what we have found is that the milk alternatives, the plant-based alternate milk alternatives are gen are, are the entry route into the category and then followed by that it tends to be burgers, um, is the next, uh, burger alternatives, uh, plant-based burger alternatives followed by the, the hot dogs, the sausage, the crumbles, and all of the other things, um, and what's interesting too is that we have found from consumers the newer, uh, entrance to the, the. Uh, categories, uh, whether it's burgers or crumbles, etc. um, they're often doing it too for safety reasons because they've lost trust even though they might be carnivores because 1 in 5 plant-based purchasers call themselves carnivores. Um, they're, they tend not to eat as much meat at home or they have a lot of, uh, you know, a little bit of uh resistance to to preparing meat at home for a variety of. Reasons, uh, you know, it's anything from skill level all the way up to, you know, safety precautions with a lot of the, the meat recalls and especially now with the pandemic and a lot of things in the news about meat, so they feel that, um, the plant-based proteins last a lot longer. They're, they're generally already seasoned or semi-prepared, so they're very easy to cook for someone who doesn't have a lot of like inspiration or wherewithal, um, in, in the kitchen that evening on that particular occasion.

Carol Ortenberg [15:15] TK, we've certainly seen that food service has contributed uh to driving this trial as well, you know, whether it's a veggie grill or a Burger King, going in and trying new plant-based alternatives. How have you seen this channel really impact the category?

Speaker 6 [15:34] Uh yeah, I think uh we, we started back in 2006, I think, uh, near that tail end of the health focused side of it that Jamie talked about, and uh uh what we're able to do in food services, we're able to prepare it and prepare it properly. And uh uh the products have come a long way since 2006, we used to make our own tempe and Seitan and And then uh Gardine came out with their chicken, Tofurky was already out with their products, and today you have Beyond Meat, and so, preparation, I think has become easier, but at the same time, a lot of consumers don't want to go through their own prep work and their own learning. And so, uh, that's what restaurants like Veggie Grill do. We, we, we take the best plant-based products, the best proteins. And then we put the right toppings on them, put them in the right recipes, and create familiar, tasty, uh, uh, menu items that give people that opportunity to try it without having to do too much or learn too much on their own.

Carol Ortenberg [16:37] Do those consumers tend to convert and then eventually purchase and store these plant-based products themselves, or are you kind of one or the other?

Speaker 6 [16:47] Yeah, I think, uh, I think it's both, um, anecdotally, we don't have data on that, but, uh, I certainly hear a lot of people come to me and say, hey, I, I never knew plant-based food could taste so, uh, tastes like this, when they come into Veggie Grill. They, they were brought in by a friend, so that's kind of another thing that food service, uh. Uh, provides is we have a lot of, uh, vegetarians or, uh, vegans who bring in their friends who are meat eaters, and say, hey, just try it, come in, give it a shot, and then once they try it though, wow, I never knew, uh, a burger could taste this much like meat, or a chicken sandwich, it could taste like chicken, and so that gets them into the category, for sure.

Carol Ortenberg [17:26] I know many of you all are in other major city centers, uh, TK, a lot of the restaurants you were discussing, uh, are in, uh, Boston. We have one, for example. What I'm curious is, are we living in little bubbles? How does the mainstream. Consumer feel about plant protein is what I'm wondering, you know, a lot of these brands talk about accessibility and wanting to move towards the center of the country, um, and I'm just curious if that has happened or if we see this happening. Melissa, what, what has the Hartman Group found?

Speaker 3 [18:03] We found that it's it's really across the board that more and more consumers, uh, you know, it's like 51% of consumers have purchased plant-based protein in the last 3 months. So there are so many more product introductions and opportunities available and even to TK's point about, uh, these consumers who. are more oriented towards plant-based, they are more likely to go to fast casual than say a QSR. So again, that's like a great opportunity. So with more fast casual uh available throughout the country, the little chains and chainlets that that creates a lot of opportunity and awareness for consumers. But what we really have found is that I, I mentioned this earlier is that it is the millennial and the Gen Z consumer who's driving this. They tend to be a little bit higher educated and they tend to also be more in urban and suburban areas so and that's across the country. It isn't just in, you know, the university towns and the coasts at this stage. So it's, it's really spreading and it is driven very much as we've already said by by this health notion. And the aspiration towards sustainability, um, but the really interesting is also discovery so I think that's the other thing too is because there's an ease that, uh, plant-based proteins can really, uh, assist consumers, um, in the kitchen or make easy decisions when they're out at a fast casual. So it's becoming increasingly easier for consumers to make that choice and feel good about it.

Speaker 4 [19:37] Yeah, I, I, I'd like to add something in there and I have no data to back this up because I'm just the back end ops person and have nothing to do with front end marketing or sales. Uh, but even in our own life, I see, you know, my kids are, are, are growing up, they're 12 and 16, they care about, uh, social missions, environmental missions differently than, you know, I may have, or, um, folks in our. Generation and so it's, it becomes an easy conversation to have and why some of those decisions can be helpful and impactful and frankly, they're learning about a lot of this stuff in school, right? They come home and say to me, well, not home anymore, but they come off the computer screen and say to me, hey, we talked about this, um, you know, is this true? Or how do we continue to, to, to help, uh, you know, the environment moving forward. And so we have those real conversations and uh by the way, they are intimidated and afraid of some plant proteins and like love and are so attached to others definitely the dairy category uh drives them uh more significantly but uh I I find that that kind of. Conversation at home and breaking down I think the conversations that the next generation is hearing uh around them help to really remove the the walls of uh of uncomfortability and they want to extend um uh into trial.

Speaker 2 [21:02] I'd like to add my own kind of anecdotal experience, you know, I'm a vegan. We manufacture in Oregon, and while the Portland bubble is pretty big and pretty powerful, we're an hour away and we're not really in that. So we manufacture in a small town called Hood River, very outdoorsy, very health oriented, and I've definitely seen a shift in the menu offerings in our town. You know, you can, you can have a vegan offering, a vegan option at pretty much any restaurant you want in Hood River, as long as it's a burger. So we're at the earliest stages, and we need product diversity, I think, and really it really comes down to decisions that are made by those gatekeepers, you know, the people who decide what's on the menu, the people who decide what's on the grocery store shelves. I think that the appetite for these products is there. The consumers want these products, but their ability to get to them is somewhat a function of where they live. If you're in a A downtown environment you probably have lots of cool grocery stores you can go to and lots of options you can get to. We're all reading about this stuff on social media and we all want to try it, but we don't always have access to it. So I think distribution, um, you know, really progressive thinking at the category level is really going to drive the growth of this industry going forward.

Speaker 6 [22:14] Yeah, I'll jump in as well. Um, yeah, if you look at what's happened in the last 14 years since I've been in this, uh, space, it's amazing, right? Like the fact that you can go to almost any restaurant and have a vegan item is pretty amazing versus where we were. Uh, a decade ago, and, uh, yeah, it's still hard, uh, like in LA, like, if I go to a restaurant and they don't have vegan items marked, it's like, well, what's, what's your problem? Uh, but, uh, you know, certainly other parts of the country aren't quite there. Uh, but I think the progress is clearly happening every year. And uh so it's just, uh, it's continuing to happen and it's started here on the coasts, and then I then quickly making its way. It starts in some of the metros, because that's, when you look at this generational shift, you have a higher density of the millennials and Gen Z's in the metro areas, but, uh, uh, it's, it's continuing to push outwards every uh every day.

Speaker 5 [23:16] Well, I might as well jump into or round it out. But I, I love this discussion. I think that what happens in food service is super impactful to what we experienced on the retail side. It's a fantastic way for customers to sample product and reach customers that otherwise, I think to everyone's point, may not have a gatekeeper who allowed that product to be available to them. Likely that's a retailer that maybe some of those stores, uh, middle America or different areas, maybe just, they didn't want to take the chance because it is a pretty big opportunity cost to do so. So what we're seeing is fantastic when that translates. We've certainly seen it on the fluid side, on the creamer or barista products uh lineup, that's, that's been a fantastic entry point, which has been super beneficial to the retail channels. I would say the one thing I would add that's really unique lately is that the branding has gone along with the products that are used in service. And for a long time, I think, Jamie, to your point about the health phase, uh, the, the well-being sort of uh earlier stages of plant-based protein, you would frequently find products in some of the Uh, food service outlets, but you never knew what it was. It wasn't necessarily associated with a specific brand, and so when that customer went back to a retailer to buy it, they didn't know what they were really looking for, and I think it does show up differently on your plate than it does on the retail shelves. And so what we're seeing with the branding going along with the expansion into all sorts of food service avenues, it's the instant get it, they know exactly what they're buying, so it's almost like looking at UPC to UPC when they go back into retail, although sometimes the formulations are slightly different to make sure they can execute a food service, of course.

Carol Ortenberg [25:09] Well, Lee, you are one of those gatekeepers. Um, what are your goals when you're merchandizing the set and thinking about the assortment of the products you have, as well as, you know, where does price come into play, uh, in introducing new customers and building out that set?

Speaker 5 [25:29] Yeah, for sure, and you're right, I am one of the gatekeepers, had to call it out. Uh, we always want to deliver a great customer experience, and that can mean on a very basic level, offering a need state that they're looking for, or something that maybe they don't know they're looking for. At Whole Foods, we've always prided ourselves on having that cutting edge innovation. Plant-based protein is certainly a category where we'd like to lean in. And make sure that we're taking chances and offering products that could provide a new shopping occasion for our customers. That's going to continually be important to us. Uh, we're very happy with the customer satisfaction we have with the steps and the product offerings, and that's going to continue to be a focus. I would say price is, is crucially important, absolutely. Especially, especially when you consider in comparison to what the purchase that's being offset costs the customer. So the price per ounce really gets to be pretty important to the savvy customer. I think the, depending on the demographic, they may be willing to spring for a pricier item once. There's a difference though than uh what happens after that and if they're willing to incur that cost on an ongoing basis. So depending on the retailer strategy, uh we certainly have ours, we find a way to deliver value that can be done through everyday price, promotion, brand positioning, all sorts of Different levers that we can pull to make sure we're offering that value. So that's going to continue to be a very big focus area, and I would say also one that would really help with household penetration, especially larger families where maybe there isn't as much household penetration and cost is even more important.

Speaker 2 [27:17] And I'd like to add, I think that the that we understand that as manufacturers we understand what our mandate is. I think there are some kind of inequities out there. We're fighting, you're sort of competing against products that have subsidies that we don't have the advantages of economies of scale that we haven't achieved yet too, but I do think that we all understand the mandate is to achieve price parity or even improve on pricing, you know, it's possible these, these inputs that we're talking about, these ingredient inputs are more. Efficient and there should be an avenue toward even price reduction over the long term. We have a lot of hurdles to get through, but I think that we know that's the goal. We want to put the consumer in the position of choosing between animal meat and plant-based meat just based on preference and not based on how much money they have in their bank account.

Speaker 6 [28:08] Yeah, I'll, I'll, I'll definitely second that, which is, uh, um, you know, the reason a lot of these plant-based products cost more is because of the inputs, and, uh, everybody, I think in the plant-based world wants to bring their prices down to equivalent. To animal, animal products, but, uh, the subsidies, uh, uh, make it impossible today. And so the third real, you know, there's, there's a scale aspect that's happening, that's great, that's make, make in demand, that's bringing prices down and increasing supply, uh, but the third, uh, 3rd kind of gatekeeper is the government, and like the subsidies, and so. Uh, hopefully at some point in, in not in the not too distant future, we'll get, uh, more support from, uh, from the government to help bring the prices on par with animal products.

Speaker 3 [28:57] And and I'll just um jump in there and just say that in our, our most recent uh survey on talking to plant-based purchasers, the top reason um of drawbacks of purchasing was that they were too expensive, 38% they were too too expensive compared to non plant-based purchasers who were not. Seeking them was 50% so it really just goes to show that consumers, they, they tell us this in qualitative and we find it in our surveys and quantitative that they, they, they do that comparison between the cost of meat as well as um compared to the cost of the plant-based, um, and, and they just don't have. The awareness of the, the subsidies and, and all of the economies of scale and they, they just feel like, well, meat is that whether they appreciate it or not they see that as the it makes sense to have the premium, uh, price tag so there, there's a little bit of a learning curve and the more they learn about it, the more they learn about the ingredient sourcing because that's what they're demanding, um, they're willing to pay that price when they know that narrative is rich and strong regarding that sourcing and that it is, is less commoditized if you will.

Carol Ortenberg [30:07] Melissa, you and I have talked about a lot about the wide range of product ingredients and positioning we're seeing in this category, uh, that you've, uh, come across it at City Ops and City Capital. Um, can all brands do you think actually achieve that scale, or are there some products. That are just so forward thinking that it's gonna take them longer to achieve that goal, even if that is what they ultimately want. And, and what do they need to, what do brands need to do if they really want to scale their businesses? What do they need to be thinking about?

Speaker 4 [30:44] Yeah, very good question, and I think coupled with uh not a perfect one answer solution. Um, it really takes a village to build infrastructure, uh, for accessibility here for scale. That's ingredient, supply, uh, manufacturing, equipment, food science. Uh, there's a tremendous amount of support that the industry needs, uh, to really move ahead. I, I mean, we're talking about, you know, hundreds. Of years of of cultivating animal products and uh bringing them efficiently to market. I obviously use that in quotes um that that we're really competing with here in a matter of, you know, a decade or two. it's clearly accelerated some. There's a tremendous amount of energy and focus on it. There are large companies, ingredient companies, supply companies paying attention. Uh, but I think, um, it's building the, the, the blocks and pieces of true, uh, you know, foundational support in order to get there. Sure, there are forward thinking, um, uh, you know, approaches, and I don't know that, um, that that's a bad thing, and I also don't know that that's ever gonna stop. That's what happens in innovation and in food, um, but I, I think. The least complex thing to solve first is making sure there's enough manufacturing support, right, for small batch, uh, into medium batch size, um, you know, product Tofurkey is a great example of having to build really their own, right? And, and a lot of these, uh, plant-based meat companies have had to go that route in order to get the scale, uh, that they're really looking. Looking for, um, I think beyond that it's, uh, really investing in the innovation and science part of how all these inputs, uh, react together because some of them are processing based, some of them are just ingredient blend based, um, and, and, and we will find those efficiencies, but it takes a lot of people, a lot of time and a lot of effort. Efort and energy, I think the average plant-based company ends up needing to raise more money than if you were to go out there and start the next popcorn business, right? Uh, all of that has infrastructure, uh, already put together, um, so now you're building a brand. In this case, uh, a lot of these plant-based businesses are having to literally build, uh, the support to grow.

Speaker 2 [33:18] I'd also like to add sort of the experiences we've had and how they've changed over time with respect to co-manufacturing, because yeah, there's a massive capital outlay to build a plant, and we're in a moment where our technology is shifting quickly too. So by the time you invest and install all this equipment, maybe there's a new technology and you tear that out and put something new in. It's a lot of risk and especially for an early stage company. Tofurkey over the years has reached out to co-manufacturing partners to make products that we didn't want to invest in creating the processing capability ourselves for, and those conversations have shifted a lot and shifted in a really good way for our industry. Initially 10 years ago or even prior to that, there was a lot of skepticism. There wasn't a lot of buy-in, and the people who were willing to work with you tended to be small scale and hungry for business, and that meant Small scale meant that they were inefficient too, and that really became a pricing problem, really ate away at margin, ended up with a higher shelf price, and it wasn't as practical. We've got a new generation. Well, now that there's this mainstream acceptance, some manufacturers understand that there's a huge opportunity for them as well. And now those conversations are a lot different. You don't start by educating them about plant-based. You don't have to convince them that there are enough of those people out there to actually support, you know, this product line you're trying to launch. There's an appetite for manufacturing those products now. They're coming to us. They're excited about working in plant-based. They're, they, they have strategic goals to include plant-based processes or products in their, in their portfolios too. So that creates opportunities for Really interesting cool brands that maybe aren't as well funded. I don't think that everybody necessarily has to go into the, you know, venture rounds and give away all their equity and, and really take on all that risk. There, there, there's another kind of business model now that we're seeing be successful right before our very eyes that really wasn't available to us as an industry not that long ago.

Speaker 5 [35:17] And I think just from my perspective, Almost strictly as a, a student of the game, this is the part that, you know, I find absolutely fascinating, and we have all sorts of products brought to us that from the manufacturing side might have a completely different background. Because there are so many different approaches to how you can come up with a great end product that are just quite an array of more traditional manufacturing to more technology forward, ah, sort of established processes, which is, it's a really interesting time in the industry. I just, I do want to extend sincere gratitude to what brands like Tofurky have done over the years of Having a vision, having a dream, committing to it, investing in it and going for it, because I really feel like the segment wouldn't have been here if those brands didn't do that. And it's super fascinating to see that foundation and watch the rest of the industry build off of it and get creative with new solutions for a different customer experience.

Carol Ortenberg [36:27] Well, it's interesting we're having this conversation of manufacturing, and I, I, this came up before the idea of how, you know, building out a supply chain, building out manufacturing compared to meat. Uh, but now we're seeing meat get into plant-based protein. So, uh, you know, you have companies like Kellogg's, like Tyson, uh, Launching their own alternatives. Does the, how does the industry, how do you all kind of feel about that, and how have you seen consumers respond to meat producers getting into plant-based products? Are they aware of who the end producer of these items are? I'll throw this out to the wider group if anyone has some, uh, strong feelings on this.

Speaker 2 [37:11] I have, I have some feelings, um. I, you know, first and foremost I'd say this is a sign of success. This means that as an industry we're winning, and I'm thrilled by that, and I think that the ability of really big CPG companies to push plant-based broader and into the mainstream and really make it an everyday part of people's lives, that's awesome. I would draw a distinction though, because another way that they're getting involved is just supplementing real meat products with plant proteins. I'm less enthused about that. I think that that starts to confuse people, you know, the standard American diet is not lacking in protein. We don't need to supplement animal proteins with other proteins. I think it's great that they're sort of diluting the environmental and, you know, other impacts by, you know, selling a little less meat and a little more plant-based protein, but I think the risk of consumer confusion. Uh, is, is pretty high there, and I, I, I think it's, it's, it's not really good for the consumer ultimately. I think there's a risk that they don't actually know what they're purchasing, and I don't, I don't love that.

Speaker 3 [38:16] We actually found that in our research that the plant-based purchasers, 56% of them were interested in purchasing these blended burgers, for example, or were already buying them. And because many of these plant-based purchasers, because that's a growing demographic, they are, they claim to be carnivores. 1 in 5 tend to call themselves carnivores. There's a wider market actually, and the more. The interesting thing about it is that the 30% of non-purchasers of plant-based proteins said that they were really interested or already buying the blended burger, um, and that's even higher than the 21% who are interested in the Impossible Burger. So I think we have to make sure that we're paying attention to to the consumer aspirations around this so that we're not going to get consumers across America or the world for that matter to stop eating meat. That's just not gonna, but what. We hear a lot of consumers saying is that they would like to see uh factory farming uh shift away towards more ethical, more humane. So provided that the blended burger or whatever the the end product is contains a more ethical, humanely treated animal product along with that blended, you know, whether it's the mushrooms or whatever, whatever that that additional. Uh, plant-based, uh, origin is lentils, etc. uh, there is a wider, um, segment of consumers who's willing to incorporate that for taste, um, for flavor, and to a large extent to for that nutrition that they still continue to feel that meat products provide that oftentimes the, uh, the that is lacking in, in the plant-based.

Speaker 6 [40:06] I'm definitely uh in Jamie's camp on this one. I, I, uh, certainly, uh, I kind of look at it as greenwashing in a certain respect, right? Like they're just trying to uh throw a little plant protein in there, and then get the benefit of the plant-based movement, um. Uh, so I certainly don't, uh, yeah, I, I guess if, if they're gonna make a choice between eating meat and eating a blended meat product, I would, uh, uh, I think the blended meat product has a purpose, but, I'd rather get them eating a fully plant-based product, when they, when they wanna reduce their impact and really focus on a more ethical supply chain and a more environmentally friendly supply chain, start, uh, you know, making it 100% plant-based, but we'll see, we'll see how the consumer evolves. It shows that I think there's more work to be done for the plant-based movement to get people to really understand the benefits of 100% plant-based, and hey, if you're gonna try and make a difference, why don't you really make a difference.

Speaker 4 [41:07] Well, uh, so I have a question actually for TK and Jamie on this based on the, the, uh, the thoughts around that. I sort of look at the blended, uh, products as a bridge of being slightly less intimidating for folks who may be. Concerned about what it is they do with a plant-based product, uh, or what it would taste like and then ultimately, uh, get to a place of education or feeling more comfortable and making their way to a full plant-based product. I, I'm wondering if you guys see it that way or if you actually see it that, um, they'll never leave meat then as a result of that.

Speaker 6 [41:44] Yeah, so I'll, I'll jump in. Yeah, so that's the, that's the question, the big question. So I, I see, see it as a, a crutch, not a bridge, and, uh, so, you know, that, you know, we'll see, we'll see how it evolves.

Speaker 2 [41:59] Well, I think, you know, a lot of these consumer conversations, if you call, call them that, they're all, they're aspirational, right? And so, you know, for, for whatever reason, people are inspired to achieve this change in their lives, and I think. If they don't really understand that this is not really fully plant-based, and I think there's a lot of risk of that just in terms of the way that products are marketed, both face panels as well as, you know, the, the typical consumer marketing, but I think the risk is that they're going to think that they arrived, you know, I have interesting conversations with people who maybe I'm wearing a a like a plant-based brand shirt or something, and they're like, oh, I'm plant-based also. I've, I've been asking this question for 5 years or more. Oh, does that mean you're vegan? And some of them clearly don't know what plant-based is, and there are always, you have a lot of consumers out there that don't necessarily have the level of knowledge that we do too. And I feel like they're, we're kind of setting this aspirational goal out there, but maybe misleading them into thinking that they've already arrived, and there's a lot of room for movement there still, you know, a blended product is really not plant-based. It's not even close to plant-based, and I think that You know, you're still contributing to all those things you're trying to avoid, you know, the, the harm to the environment, for example, being kind of very, uh, first and foremost in my mind right now as we have wildfires raging outside.

Speaker 3 [43:21] Um, I was just gonna add to that too in the many conversations I've had over the years, you know, over 2025 years talking to consumers in their homes and their pantries, picking around their cupboards and, and so forth, um, there is increasing concern though with many of the plant-based products, um, regarding the processing and ingredients. So we have a number of more, you know, they're these, these consumers are more health oriented. They read more labels than non plant based, uh, consumers, so they are more hyper aware of, um, whether, uh, an ingredient, uh, is genetically modified or how it's processed, the hype all the hyper processing that goes involved with it, so it's in some sort of contradiction, uh, from what we've, we've heard from consumers over the years is that many of the plant-based products tend to be more. process, um, so there is that that conflicting feeling for the consumer when the whole movement is really towards it's, it's really what the goal is it's like their, uh, their motivation is, um, fresher, less processed, more natural, you know, whatever that that necessarily means to them so there is that, that, that rub about the the hyper processing that is, uh, reflected in the long lists, um, in, in many. Of the introductions out there and and the concern over um how the soy is processed or the pea protein is there glyphosate in that so there's more and more concern and more and more awareness of the mainstream consumer moving forward so that's something that we have to consider too if if the the goal is for everyone to become plant-based, that's, that's almost unachievable. So to be able to uh speak to them. In a language where the processing and the ingredient sourcing uh is is more uh compelling and transparent to them that is really gonna be one of the keys uh to to incorporate more consumers into the the plant based or what is really maybe it's more plant rich, um, and making sure there's more vegetables it's, it's not just hyper uh processed uh carbohydrates that are, um, under the guise of, of plant based.

Speaker 6 [45:32] Yeah, so I, I definitely have, uh, uh, been living that, I have strong opinions around that. And, uh, um, so, basically, you know, it, there's, there's a reason for, uh, meat alternatives, and there's a reason to eat kale and whole grains, and beans, and lentils, and nuts and seeds. Those are all plant-based products that are as healthy, the, you know, the ultimate in health. Right? And so there's a consumer education that is just not there across uh the majority of the country, and uh so that's another problem, right? That, uh, you know, people need to understand what, you know, what nutrient-dense food really is, and the fact that you can get all the protein you need from beans, lentils, nuts, seeds, and whole grains. And uh so that's happening too, right? And so there's a, but there's certain people who just can't, you know, have become somewhat addicted to the taste of concentrated protein and concentrated fat. And that's what meat is, and that's what meat alternatives replicate in a much more ethical way. And, uh, and if you really dig into the studies, you have uh less risk of heart disease, cancer, uh, when you're eating plant proteins instead of animal proteins. But, you know, consumers are gonna have. To, uh, do their own research, you know, look at the stu, you know, the studies are coming out every day. There's been a, there was a recent study just, that just came out a month ago, talking about the reduced risk of, uh, cardiovascular disease when you're eating meat alternatives versus meat itself. And uh. Um, but, hey, if, if health is your number one goal, uh, yeah, you should choose a whole, uh, uh, um, a plant-based, uh, whole foods diet, right? And then you're getting the ultimate in health. But, uh, you know, it's, it's gonna be an ongoing process, and, uh, you know, when you say impossible, I tend to Uh, disagree, cause I've seen how far things have come in the last 14 years. Like, if you were to talk about having a $10 billion public plant-based company 14 years ago, you'd say that was impossible. So, uh, the progress we've made in the last 14 years has been, been amazing, and, uh, so I'm, I think there's a, there's a big opportunity and uh it's, it's up to all of us to continue to push, push the consumer forward.

Speaker 5 [47:55] Yeah, I, I love this conversation cause I really think it. It hits on what truly is the goal of the consumer and what's motivating their behavior. And I think there are so many different perspectives that each customer comes at this challenge with. It could be to reduce overall meat consumption, it could be to ultimately eat products with a cleaner ingredient panel and less manufacturing behind it. Uh, but some of these things don't all jive with each other, right? They, they don't all achieve the same goal, which makes it, for us, at least as a retailer, even more important to offer that breadth of option to them. So that they can find their way, and then they can speak back to us and tell us what they're looking for. And I certainly, I, I can't help but to read the words behind ETK to craft food that is good for our lives and for our future, and I think that uh there's an alignment that comes from a lot of people that that is their mission as well. Uh, how they get there may have a very different path though, and I think um what's interesting to me around the blended burger conversation. if the customer starts to adopt that behavior and starts eating with more of the the blended proteins. I'm curious if eventually we'll see they find, hey, you know what, I actually, I might feel different. Hopefully it's better, it might not be, depending on what's the um plant-based protein and the process that went into it, but they'll potentially find a difference in how they're feeling and how their body is reacting to it, and so that'll start to drive some behavior as well. But I think it's just a, a really interesting conversation that we'll continue to see evolve and Helps us model out what we bring to ourselves as the gatekeepers as well, but we certainly want to provide those options to help them make the decision.

Speaker 2 [49:49] I'd also say like what we're talking about points out some deficiencies in the language that we have around these foods. Processed is a really broad term. It can encompass things just like size reduction is a process, you know, chopping broccoli in your kitchen. That's, that's a process. That's not what people are really trying to avoid, but I think that we really lack the right terminology to draw those distinctions. So Melissa's a savvy kind of insider, and she's saying hyperprocessed, and I think that's a distinction that You know, is useful because that's something that we think about also, like what would, you know, as people running Tofurkey and also consuming Tofurkey, what, what do we want to eat? And I think there are more and less attractive processes out there. We try to avoid the ones that kind of change the chemical makeup of our products, but we, we definitely process our foods. But you know, nothing, nothing that you wouldn't see in your own kitchen. I think you could probably do a really good job of replicating practically any Tofurkey product using A standard kitchen equipment. So I'm hoping that that means that this conversation evolves a little bit. I think, you know, whole, it's really easy on the extremes. There's kind of that whole plant-based sort of diet that TK talked about. There are like purely synthetic things, you know, we're growing real meat in petri dishes right now too, so it's, I think that there is enough breadth in that word that we need to start thinking about, thinking about segmenting it in ways that resonate with consumers. We lack the language right now. It's something that we at Tofurkey think about a lot.

Speaker 4 [51:20] Well, you know, and, and I think about the word process too and think that people are judging plant-based products that are hyperprocessed, let's use the term correctly, but you open their cabinet and they have a ton of other product profiles that they are consuming. Uh, that are hyper processed, um, and, and somehow, uh, that has become OK, uh, but in the plant-based world, uh, uh, you know, for me, really we're like just in the beginning stages of this. So, uh, I very much believe that price will come down. I very much believe processing will reduce. I, I very much believe, um. You know, will, will become more wholesome, uh, as an alternative, but it, it's just this interesting dichotomy that when you look at, uh, diets, there's judging, uh, in this direction that just doesn't exist in, in 95% of what someone, uh, oftentimes is willing to consume, even by the way, the health. Consumer, right, uh, people who think they are eating healthy, um, it, it's, it, there's a very small portion of us who really pay attention, I think, to every single thing they consume, uh, and, and, and a much broader audience, um, who think they're making better choices but really, um, sometimes aren't.

Speaker 2 [52:41] We were also talking earlier about brand, and here's where brand actually has a lot of utility, you know, if a brand kind of stakes out what it represents, you know, what, what, what processes it's willing to indulge in and what ones it won't, you know, whether it's going to use GMO ingredients or not, that starts to make this easier for consumers too. They can just sort of vet the brand and then know that any product that comes out under that brand umbrella is going to, you know, kind of be made with those ideals in mind. So, you know. Maybe that's one of the solutions is really educating people about our own brands.

Speaker 3 [53:16] I wholeheartedly agree with you on that, Jamie, and what we found too is that yes, consumers are there's contradictions all over the place, but it really depends upon the occasion so we'll talk to um a more health oriented consumer who uh is more plant-based oriented and on some occasions they, they know they might have that. Awareness around health and wellness, but on some occasions they want that chicken nugget from Morningstar Farms that that they ate, you know, in their freshman year of college because it, it, it's now become nostalgic, whereas, you know, for someone my age like that wasn't as, you know, there are other things that would be more nostalgic, but for the younger consumer, the, these Morningstar farms and these more the, the early entrance in some of those places, the, the, uh. Corn dogs with uh you know that are made from veggies and all that kind of that that is the nostalgic moment that it will then becomes the occasion so it's not as often so yeah when we're talking about other things that are just loaded with all kinds of ingredients in their pantries, that's the consumer we're messy mess consumers are messy each and every one of us are and no one, you know, we're, we're not there. Here to judge anyone based on their um on what's in you know what's going on what they're consuming but it was so it really comes down to that moment of like when you are consuming that this is it's really about the meal occasion so we're seeing a lot of these plant based proteins different than snacks and some of the other plant-based oriented things out there that it's more oriented towards a meal occasion so a meal occasion is held to a higher standard. So that is one of the other critical aspects to make sure that we are paying more attention and to Jamie, to your point too that you know there's so much more we can do to convey through narratives to storytelling based on what those ingredients are and you know from seed to to plate essentially but I really can't emphasize enough how important that occasion is because we find all kinds of brands and ingredients that you know it's not just a very um you know typical. The sphere of health and wellness or sustainability oriented consumer that's gonna have just the rice and beans and some of like the, the much more cleanly oriented plant-based products they're gonna have a variety of things in their pantry that speak to the uh the variety of occasions that they, you know, whims and instrumental versus more savoring that they

Speaker 4 [55:30] seek on a daily

Carol Ortenberg [55:31] basis. I appreciate this conversation around meal occasions, um. Lee, there's certainly a lot of buzz around the, you know, sort of bleeds like meat segment. Have you guys found that is this the tip of the spear that's driving the category, or are there room for meat alternatives still like, uh, you know, a traditional veggie burger, um, in consumers' minds? Um, what, what are you seeing in stores?

Speaker 5 [56:01] Yeah, it definitely comes down to customer segmentation. It really depends on the customer who's shopping those products, and the leaves like meat customer is coming likely from a very different place than the tofu die-hard or the millennial who's starting to eat more plant-based proteins on a regular basis. You know, maybe they really like the convenience factor, I think to everyone's point, it's prepared, it's cooked, uh, sometimes it's flavored, it's ready to roll. So, it's, I would say driving, but, you know, when you start to think about the size of the industry that we're tapping into, it's really almost two different conversations, or potentially more than two. So it, I, yes, you could say that, but I wouldn't necessarily say that's the sole factor. There are lots of customers who are being turned on to more traditional plant-based proteins. And that's great to see. We're really excited about the traction that has come as a result across all sorts of different customer segmentations.

Speaker 6 [57:04] Yeah, I would, uh, I was, I would say I would add in, uh, um, definitely customer segmentation, cause, uh, at Veggie Grill, we have 3 burgers. We have a Beyond Meat burger, we have a Tempe burger, and we have a house veggie burger, right? And they all meet different occasions, which, which Melissa brought up, right? It's all about. You know, do you, are you in your indulgent, hey, I just want some familiar comfort food, and it's a Friday night, or, or whatever, where, whenever you wanna celebrate with a little bit more comfort, you got our Beyond Burger, or if you're early in your plant-based journey, and you just, you wanna stay with familiar taste profiles, you have your Beyond Burger. But if you're in a different piece of your plant-based journey, where you're looking for something a little bit more veggie-oriented, we have our house veggie burger, and uh then we have our tempe. Burger, which is a, you know, it is a fermented soybeans and grains, and, uh, uh, and, you know, so it's, it's about this journey, it's about this meal occasion. I will say, you know, the, the Beyond Burger is our top seller. So there's a lot more people in that segmentation who are traditional meat eaters who, who want something that tastes like meat, but, uh, these days, all those segments are, you know, have a decent uh size, and uh you can see the categories associated with, with each of them.

Speaker 2 [58:22] It's also going to be interesting to see how the preferences of consumers evolve now that we're not quite so shackled to animal protein being center of plate. We're starting to see generations of young adults who that was not their experience, and so it's going to give a different mandate to manufacturers ultimately. It won't be necessarily, we'll see how it plays out, but won't, it won't necessarily be has to be like meat. It might just be good and healthy and good for the environment. And high protein, for example, um, that's, it's going to change for sure, uh, but we don't, I guess we can't predict which direction it'll go in, but it doesn't have to be meat necessarily.

Carol Ortenberg [59:04] Well, we're about out of time. Um, I'd love to wrap up by asking you guys to do just what Jamie was doing a little bit of and project in the future. Uh, where do you see this going? Are we gonna be meeting again in 5 years and, and talking about cellular meat? Uh, will bleeds like meat, looks like meat still be cutting edge, and, and more importantly, you know, what do brands need to do to stay relevant? I'd love to throw this out there for final thoughts from you guys.

Speaker 3 [59:34] I think it's really important that it's, it's less about trying to compete against meat and more about celebrating the ingredients themselves, um, and I think that that's where we're going long term and of course we've talked a lot about the idea of making sure that there are options for consumers on a variety of occasions as they are on their plant-based journey, but long term as the more and more consumers uh you with social media and more. Access it doesn't matter what city or where you live in the country that the awareness of new brands is continuing to rise, especially for that younger consumer so their demand for transparency around how things are grown, um, and comparing it against factory farmed meat, for example, um, is going to be an increasing issue of the, the. Uh, as the consumer continues that journey and so they're going to be looking for that transparency and, and how those grains, seeds, beans, whatever the ingredient is that's making its way into that plant-based protein product, how it's sourced, how it's grown, and, uh, more about that story about chemical inputs as well.

Speaker 6 [1:00:42] Yeah, I'll, I'll, I'll say, uh, hey, we're on, uh, we're on that flywheel of, you know, this, this is just gonna keep accelerating, uh, because there's better products coming to market, there's more consumer education, it's becoming more part of culture, right? We got kids growing up now, and, and a lot more vegetarians and vegans amongst their peer set. Um, so I think we're, and then the, you know, when the education around health, the education around the environment. Um, you know, we talked about the government, that's, that's a big factor, you know, in terms of where and how quickly it can get to, uh, the full country versus more of the, uh, the, the half of the country that can afford to pay a little bit of a premium for these products. Um, so, I think we're gonna see a lot of momentum. It's just a matter of how, how far we could take it in terms of the different demographic groups, uh, based on, uh, I think the government factors.

Speaker 2 [1:01:40] In addition to the really good points that are made already, I'd also say that we're going to see some shifts in the grocery stores too, like the way, the way and the where in the grocery store that these products are merchandis, I think is going to go through some changes as well, and hopefully we see these sets expand. Um, they're small enough now that consumers don't have a lot of options for, you know, multiple brands within the same subcategory, for example, and I think that that's going to change, and I think that's going to allow people to find that, oh, I might not have liked that plant-based sausage, but now there are 3 others to choose from, 3 other brands to choose from. So that's a, that's a pretty near term change that I see on the horizon.

Speaker 5 [1:02:18] Feels like a good segue into retail, so I'll jump in. Uh, this will behave like many other categories. There will be an innovation curve with early adopters, it will hit mainstream, it'll become a staple product. I think what's different though is that there's a whole lot more um firepower and energy behind it because of the velocities, because of the size of the market that it's starting to draw customers from. So as a result, we're seeing an accelerated path. We've all noted the capital that's gone into it. Uh, how many players there are that are jumping in, different options, different manufacturing techniques. So in a lot of ways it's really behaving on an accelerated innovation curve. I still think there is so much more runway, because what we're talking about, we've talked a lot about the burger and that's ground beef. We haven't really even touched on all the other uh animal proteins that are out there that haven't even started. So that runway will be very interesting to watch and be a part of.

Speaker 4 [1:03:22] Yeah, and, and I, I'll just end by saying I don't know that I can add anything better, uh, to all the, the feedback here because I think, um, all of those points are, are super valid and accurate. I'll end by saying one of the things that I really appreciate, I think about the industry that I have found different. Is those pushing plant proteins forward are spending time uh trying to curate for the consumer are making recipes and interaction occasions and the way they experience it, um, you know, on their website, on their social platforms and programs. Uh, so, so that it can break down walls, I think, of, um, not knowing what to do with it, uh, being intimidating, of being fearful of flavor, and so all of those things drive interest and, uh, you know, I, I, frankly, I was in an interview the other day for, uh, for one of our brands. For a chief sales officer, and I, I told the people tasting the product, please go to their website and try A, B, and C because it will blow your mind. Very different than you just buying it off the shelf and making it into whatever. You'll have a very different experience. And so, uh, the. Efforts behind these brands that they're putting forward with heart and energy and compassion um uh into flavor profiles, it it it for me has been a very different experience and I hope that that continues and will accelerate, you know, interest moving forward.

Carol Ortenberg [1:04:49] Well, everyone, you've certainly left our viewers with a lot to digest. Um, I look forward to bringing you all back together in let's say 5 to 10 years to see if our predictions were right and discuss what's changed. I'm sure it will be a whole new category by then. In the meantime, I just wanna say thank you again to all of our panelists and thank you to our sponsor, Top Health Ingredients, and for our viewers watching, we'll see you tomorrow at the product showcase. Tune in then.

Related Videos