The Art Of Making The Unfamiliar Irresistible

Introducing a novel food or beverage takes more than a great product. It takes smart positioning, relentless consumer education and a retail strategy that gives shoppers a reason to take a chance. This week’s episode features two founders bringing traditional dairy products to American consumers. Nicole Vereczkey, founder of Etelka, and Ilay Karateke, co-founder of BEZI, discuss how they're bringing traditional European and Middle Eastern dairy products to American consumers while building businesses designed to scale. The founders also share lessons on simplifying product messaging, earning retail shelf space, driving trial and velocity, managing manufacturing and distribution, and navigating the operational challenges of perishable products. Along the way, they explain why disciplined growth, the right retail partners and a willingness to say no can be just as important as having a product consumers love.

What You Will Learn

  • How to introduce unfamiliar food products by connecting them to familiar categories, occasions and consumer needs.

  • Why sampling, clear product messaging and strategic packaging are essential to driving trial and repeat purchases.

  • How to convince retail buyers that a new category can deliver incremental sales, strong velocity and value to the shelf.

  • Why operational discipline, cold-chain management and deliberate market expansion are critical to scaling perishable CPG brands.

Transcript

Note: Transcripts are automatically generated and may contain inaccuracies and spelling errors.

Ray Latif [00:05] Hey folks, I'm Ray Latif, the editor and producer of BevNET's Taste Radio podcast, and you're listening to the CPG Operator podcast. I'm filling in for Melissa Travers, who is BevNET's director of community. The CPG Operator podcast is our how do I build this series where we share practical advice and insights to help CPG brands build stronger, more successful businesses. Some of the most successful food brands in the United States have introduced Americans to foods that were already staples in other parts of the world. Think about how Siggi's and Icelandic Provisions helped popularize skyr or how Lifeway introduced kefir to a much broader audience. But getting consumers to embrace an unfamiliar food comes with challenges. How do you explain what it is, where it belongs in their routine, and why they should try it? And how do you convince retailers to take a chance on something shoppers may not even know to look for? Today we're talking with two founders bringing traditional dairy products to American consumers. Nicole Vereczkey is the founder of Etelka, which makes cottage cream, a smooth, high protein, cultured dairy product inspired by the Hungarian food turo, and Ilay Karateke is the co-founder of BEZI, which is bringing Lubna, a creamy, spreadable dairy staple from Turkey and across the Middle East and Mediterranean. To American grocery stores. Both are navigating the challenges of introducing something unfamiliar while building refrigerated food businesses that can scale. Eli, Nicole, it's so great to see you both.

Speaker 2 [01:45] Happy to be here. Thanks for having us.

Ray Latif [01:48] Yeah, Nicole, let's start with you. Tell us about Etelka. What is cottage cream and what inspired you to bring it to American consumers?

Speaker 2 [01:57] Cottage cream is like what we call the European cousin of cottage cheese. In Hungary, we call it turo or cream churro. The Germans would call it quark. The Austrians, I think, have a fun name for it called Topfen. It's this awesome in between of perhaps a Greek yogurt or a sour cream, those thicker products, and an American style cottage cheese. What makes us pretty distinct is our smooth texture, but still keeping in that high protein, whereas other products perhaps have that higher fat content. So for me, the big kind of light bulb moment of like why now the time. was here to really usher in cottage cream to the US consumer was that kind of high protein trend taking off here in the US, but also kind of missing flavors from home. I was spending a lot of time in Hungary taking care of grandparents and spending kind of summers there when I was in college and just really missing some of those flavors here in the US And so both from personal need as well as seeing kind of different trends happening here in the US, I thought now is the time to really figure out how to bring this over to the US and make it here, but in an authentic and kind of culture forward way.

Ray Latif [02:56] Well, I think your timing is spot on, as is Ilay's. Uh, Ilay, tell us all about BEZI. What Lebna is and how you've approached introducing it to shoppers who may never have heard of the product.

Speaker 3 [03:08] Yeah, so BEZI makes labne authentically in Turkey with the authentic Turkish labne base, but we kind of added a little bit of a Turk culture element to their flavors. So we launched exactly 2 years ago in New York City, bringing what I would call our version oblavne. So Turkish have one version, Lebanese have another version that's like closer to yogurt. I really believed, I mean, it's similar to Nicole's journey, this is a fantastic product that needs to be a part of the dips and spreads. It's very versatile, you can spread it on your bagel, you can eat it, eat it as a dip. You can make it like a sour cream with your curries. So what we did when we started was just like owning the labne moment and really having people to taste it and even reaching in another two years, our product is sold at Whole Foods and Target. That's the essence of what we do, keeping it a very interesting flavor base, but having people to taste it and try it in different formats. We just came up with our dippers which I'm sure will come up in our conversation today. Uh, that's our version to actually getting people to really incorporate in their day to day routine, which has our creamy yogurt dip or labne with a naturally gluten-free crackers in a more like a snack pack format, and that has been our next journey of building into more of a national brand.

Ray Latif [04:21] Getting the trial is really important. It takes great communication sometimes to get people to taste the product for the first time. You're both introducing products that have been enjoyed in other cultures for generations but aren't necessarily familiar to American shoppers. How have you approached explaining what they are without making them seem complicated? Ilay, I'd start with you.

Speaker 3 [04:41] Yeah, so when we started, we had a hard time explaining what latte is. We were saying in between like a yogurt and a cream cheese, try to really find a place, but what we came to that last moment is that our product is in the homicide. It is a dip, and yogurt and yogurt dips are having a moment. So we, unlike what the product, for us it is from scratch milk cream and cultures. We call it the creamy yogurt dip. That was a very simple way for people to imagine what it is, and that has been a copy that we've tried in our demos previously and now actually going through a bit of a rebranding change of adding that statement into our packaging as well.

Ray Latif [05:20] And Nicole, how do you talk about your products in a way that is simple and easy for people to understand?

Speaker 2 [05:28] Yeah, I think for us it goes back to even when we were naming the product. We looked at the authentic names kind of across different European cultures, Quark in German, Top Fen, Turro, and there was this moment of like, do we pick one? Do we capitalize on kind of some familiarity and some heritage there? And I ultimately made the decision to give it a new name in the US. These products weren't super. Popular here really had that much kind of cachet and so I decided to do net new cottage cream, English language across cultures. Picking cork wasn't really authentic to my heritage. Tro is a smaller population, or Hungarian is a smaller population relative to German. So all these things were going in my head and so cottage cream was really our choice of really Picking a descriptor that would anchor on that use case, right? So we are the smoother version of cottage cheese, and so anchoring on cottage, which is obviously a very trendy term right now, but using cream to really describe the difference, our creamy texture was where we kind of Found that term to really work well. And then in demos and in our language, we really do anchor on the European cousin of cottage cheese. We do sometimes, similar to what Ilay was saying, we were like anchoring like between a yogurt and a cottage cheese to kind of help people understand where we sit within the case. But as we get more demos under our belt and kind of get more feedback from consumers and more awareness, we are starting to come to the realization that BEZI did that we're just kind of narrowing down that language and really thinking about like what do we own, and we sit in the cottage cheese case at all our retailers, so really anchoring just on smooth cottage cheese or cottage cheese without the curds has been kind of where we've distilled down that marketing lingo, if you will, to really have like a streamlined version of what what cottage cream really is.

Ray Latif [07:10] People want to feel safe when they are trying new products. They want to get a sense that what they're going to eat is going to meet their expectations. And I wonder, is there a risk sometimes when you're comparing your products to something familiar that creates expectations that it can't or shouldn't meet. Ilay, let's start with you.

Speaker 3 [07:33] So I think our safe element is our flavors. We're the only ones making hot honey labne in the world. Like everything labne, the hot honey labne, doesn't exist in our heritage or in our Middle Eastern heritage, but it kind of makes sense here with that third culture element. So, your point is spot on. Like people want to feel safe, and sometimes in the like demos people say that, oh, I'm scared. I don't want to try something new. So that's the first, I think, familiarity that we have. And then the creamy yogurt dip, it does taste like a creamy yogurt dip, I think. True, we have about, I would say like 750 demos under our belts within two years. That is a wording that we believe that is safe for people versus something in between like a cream cheese and a yogurt didn't feel as safe because people have a lot of emotions about cream cheese, which I had no idea. So that's our journey of finding a word that I think feels safe, but we always come up with the flavor first, and that has been our strategy of building the new product as labne.

Ray Latif [08:29] And Nicole, if I were to encounter someone at a Whole Foods or any other grocery store and they would say, Hey, try this cottage cream, my first question would be, Well, what is this? What does this taste like? What is it going to be? What familiarity do I have with something else that might taste like this? How do you respond?

Speaker 2 [08:50] We definitely anchor on our smoothness, right, because I think any hesitation, and again going back to that safety element, a lot of hesitation actually comes from the Kurds. A lot of people are turned off by that texture, I believe. Some brands did some research and about 70 to 80% of consumers that are even in the category of purchasing cottage cheese take it home and blend it and wish it was smoother. And so that was really a key insight and we kind of create an element of safety around like we've addressed this problem for you, like come have a taste. And so we really kind of again lead with smooth or curd free or kind of these kind of texture elements in our branding and in our marketing to really kind of make the customer feel like OK. I can, I can take a taste of this, and it's not going to taste kind of curdy and almost like we get baby food a lot as a comment on cottage cheese. Like it's not going to have that lumpy texture, and then it's kind of on the customer to decide whether it tastes good, it's creamy enough, with the tart or salt, if they're coming in from yogurt, they often are like, Oh this is less tart. If they're coming in from a cottage cheese consumer, those products are often very salty, and so we don't add salt to our product. Sometimes they might be missing that. Sometimes they might Be like, oh, there's no added salt, so kind of helping them understand where we sit in kind of that entry point because usually most American consumers are quite familiar with either cottage cheese or yogurt and so it's on us to kind of understand how to help them understand how this is different and hopefully walk away thinking this is better. I'm going to switch out my cart. Yesterday we were at a demo and I got someone to drop their high protein yogurt on the table and take Nute off the table, and so those are always kind of big wins for. I'm sure BEZI feels similarly when someone drops like a hummus on the table and walks away with alane instead. It's just that little win of like, OK, like my pitch did convince you, and then that experience really sold it. Like you having that taste of it made you put down kind of an industry leader and someone that did give you that element of safety for so long, and you did take that risk and take it to purchase. So those are types of things that our team is getting more and more reps in with demos, and then we start to figure out with time.

Ray Latif [10:47] I hope you captured that interaction for social media. It would have been even better if they tossed the other product over their shoulder, perhaps, and And be like, I'm only eating Etelka going forward. I don't know. Maybe we'll see it on your Instagram at some point. Obviously I'm speaking in jest. We want to see all brands win. We want to see all products win, but there's only a limited number of products that can be on a shelf. So it's not just convincing the consumer, it's convincing the retail buyer and convincing the retail buyer first. Nicole, during the pre-call, you talked about how differently buyers at trade shows understand your product compared with everyday consumers. What have those interactions taught you about how much education is needed?

Speaker 2 [11:27] That's a great question. I'd say buyers are obviously experts in their category, and so if you do have the luck of catching a dairy buyer specifically, they've probably heard of quark or purro or have kind of tasted the whole rainbow of dairy products that We don't even know about here on the call and we're experts, right? So being able to speak about the product and process, really lean into the dairy science and what makes us different, speak about our production in terms of like what that means for shelf life, for perishability, what flavors are possible in the universe. Sometimes retailers want to know what's coming down the pipeline, if they can have exclusive flavors down the line. Etc. So really being able to speak to the science of it is like what we're we're doing at trade shows often. These are very educated folks in the space. And then also talking about like our velocities, our turns, kind of how customers are taking it off shelf and taking it at home. I do have to speak to that as well because ultimately they are creating a community for customers in this retail environment and so helping them. Or even convincing them that we do belong in the cottage cheese case, and we're helping kind of fill those shelves that are empty because there's so much velocity in the category. Those are all conversations we're having at trade shows where again in demos, it's really more about what experience are you going to have, what kind of need are we able to fill at home? Does it mean you get to put your blender away because you were blending your cottage cheese, or does it mean that you were turned off by the tartness of Greek yogurt and the salt of cottage cheese, and now there's this product in the middle that lets you kind of bring dairy into your household for the first time? Because it just wasn't working for you prior, those kind of conversations look a little different. It's way more experiential versus what really is like our secret sauce and like our process that makes cottage cream distinct on the shelf, right? So those are the two kinds of conversations you're constantly bouncing back and forth between as a founder, and sometimes it takes a second for your brain to switch, and I've definitely been in demos where I just inundate a poor customer that's like trying to check out with weird dairy science, but it's part of the process and part of the learning.

Ray Latif [13:19] Always, always learning in this business. Ilay, uh, when it comes to retail and you're speaking to a buyer for the first time, I imagine that they're interested in the cultural story behind BEZI. You know, ethnic foods are becoming more popular among mainstream Americans, but how much of the cultural or ethnic story resonates with them versus perhaps the packaging, the texture, the taste and flavor of your products?

Speaker 3 [13:50] I think we lead with incrementality. Obviously it will make us very happy if someone chooses Bessie over some other dip that has been in the shelf for like 20 years, but at the end of the day we see our category building incrementality on the shelf. So when you look into our current hummus shelves all across Uh, like a natural grocery store to a more conventional, you see about like 7 to 80% of it is hummus, and between a lot of the hummus brands, given that it is a very mature category now with Lover caker, there is a promo war between each brand. Obviously there's like really good ones with heritage with amazing flavors, but when you look from like retail buyer perspective, It's hard to justify an incrementality within that shelf. So I think what we bring as busy and as lamne as a category, I would say is just pure incrementality of something new that either it gets added into a package on top of something else when you're hosting, or we bring someone in the shelf who doesn't love hummus or doesn't like, doesn't feel like they want to have like a salsa as a dip. We just create that new opportunity, obviously, or Cultural heritage or flavors or like how we're building our business is a relative thing, but at the end of the day I think being a CPG founder now at this, I think 2 years after, I kind of would love to understand the math that goes into the grocery store, and I try to make sure for all of our buyers that we actually contribute to that map of the real estate that we're taking in the store to make sure that we're giving better returns for all of our retail partners as they have Betsy on. So that's the thing that we really try to focus on, try to prove, and the flavor and being a complete different product on the shelf is the one that helps. Obviously branding and everything helps, but I don't think that's the reason why it'll turn if you don't hit the right price point or hit the right use case or do it in the demos or any sort of a promos in the right way.

Ray Latif [15:41] Founders and brands are judged on velocity, but so are retail buyers. They need products to move off the shelf to prove that they're doing their job, that they are helping drive incremental revenue to their stores. And Nicole, I'm curious, you know, Eli talked about the package as being a key selling point for the brand, but truly it's really about price and You know, getting someone to pay a premium for something that they don't know too, too much about does take a bit of convincing from a packaging standpoint. But is there anything else specifically on shelf, shelf talkers or otherwise, that has helped get people aware of and excited about your products?

Speaker 2 [16:23] We definitely leaned into like a distinct packaging option and we really brought in like Hungarian traditional elements on Pack because we are leaning into that story and that's what makes us unique at the end of the day. It's not like we and Hungary have the American style curdy cottage cheese available. Like this is our fresh cheese, right? So those flowers. unpack our remembering of some of the Hungarian embroidery elements and stuff like that. Like I had fun with it. I really wanted it to kind of be like a love letter to my culture and my heritage, but at the same time we are mindful of like the American consumer very much so being driven to the category in the first place by health trends. And so, Yes, we have these beautiful like embroidery elements on our packaging, but we also have what I call the pill. It's this little rectangle right under our brand name that has protein front and center, the milk fat, which is 2% for our products today, and the calorie for each flavor which differs slightly by 10%. 10 calories per serving, um, right up in the center. So like you know that this is a health forward product regardless of the pretty brand name, the pretty branding, and that's I think what really is contributing to our velocities. Again, like we do benefit from being a very high velocity kind of. Frequent stock outs, empty shelves or kind of photos in my camera roll at all times. We benefit a lot from being in that category and getting a lot of trial because of that, just because of the demand and the pressure on retailers to have so much volume in these categories. But then what really does, I think, catch people's eyes despite being a newer brand and thus demanding a higher price point, we don't have the economies of scale to really pass those on to our consumer quite yet, even though we're hoping to kind of drop prices soon, is kind of. That engaging packaging, that story, that really kind of clean ingredient label. So yes, you're paying a premium, but you're also only getting milk and cultures, nothing else, no kind of nasties as we call them, to kind of push that price point down or perhaps extend our shelf life so that it's a cheaper product and we can save on operation expenses. Now we are pretty true to the Hungarian style and true to clean ingredients, and that justifies the price point and a lot of people's kind of customer viewpoint.

Ray Latif [18:33] Another way to get people excited and retail buyers excited about products and how to communicate what those products are is through innovation, making it a little bit easier, giving another point of reference that is common in their consumers' daily lives to your brand. And Eli, you mentioned Dippers, and you recently introduced your Dippers product, bringing Labna into a more familiar portable snacking format. What was the thinking behind that decision? Were you trying to make the product easier for consumers to understand, easier to use, or both?

Speaker 3 [19:06] So the whole journey was we got into Whole Foods in our first year, Mark, which was an amazing opportunity for us to understand what is actually being in the grocery store retail shop, because Bezy is just retail first and only. And through all of that like journey, I would say in the first like 3 or 4 months, it was very clear that we did fantastic in New York. The velocity was off the chart. When people eat it, it worked across the suburbs and the city, but once the presence of what Besi is, that explanatory trial factor disappears, the tubs are really hard to solve in the suburbs. It's just this. It is easier in places like SF in New York, like where there is like a general excitement and understanding of what Labne is or what different products are. It works, but when it has disappeared, it'll become a challenge. So through all of our journey, we did not want to go fast, we're not national, we're not everywhere. So we took that opportunity to really understand what could get us to be one day a national brand, and that was having trial at scale. When you think of trial and scale, it, the promos doesn't work when you're a new product. It just doesn't. It doesn't lower the barrier of entry of trying a new product. Flavors can, beautiful packaging can, but promo is barely there, I would say. So that thinking kind of led us into, once people try it, they're obsessed. That's why our velocities are what it is currently. So we're like, how can we get people to really try it and opportunities that is very clear explaining what it is. So it is labne. And crackers on top. It's a very clear visual pack. It looks very beautiful next to Sabra, and in that category, compared to, I would say, a lot of categories that Bezy is in, that has the least innovation coming from emerging brands because it's a very difficult format to do. You just need to have a factory that can like fill in the same diameter as your other factory. So like Sabra does it because it's Pepsi, but when you think about that format, it's very hard to find it anywhere else. So. There is a clear, I think, opportunity in the market by just having like a very clean snack pack that you can feed your kids with that doesn't have the rhubarb lemons and cane sugars, and also people will eat what labne is and boom, we'll have that option. So we combine that, we tease. The idea to Target, we got, we just launched that and target in two regions, um, East and West Coast, and we also got that in Whole Foods, which was compared to our journey within that first year, the residents of understanding what the value it brings from the buyers were also quite straightforward as well. And we're in the 1st 2, like 1.5 months of that, so it's very new.

Ray Latif [21:41] Well, congratulations on getting into Target and Whole Foods with the dippers. It's very exciting, very exciting for me, so that I can shop for your products a lot more easily than I had in the past. Nicole, did you, I'm looking at your website right now, did you launch just with your original or did you launch with your original and vanilla bean flavor?

Speaker 2 [21:59] So we launched with our 5.3 ounce format, which is actually a little irregular for the cottage cheese case. It's a very kind of standard play in yogurt, those kind of trial size single serving 5.3 in both original and vanilla, and then in August, end of August, beginning of September, we launched the 16 ounce, which is by far kind of our leading skew today. It's that standard size and format for cottage cheese, so we are rounding out to a 4 skew assortment today.

Ray Latif [22:25] I would think, and this is just me, the fact that you have these two SKUs and they're sitting next to each other, it makes it a little bit easier for me to understand with the vanilla bean what you're selling and what I can expect with your products. Am I alone in that thinking, or is that pretty common among your consumers?

Speaker 2 [22:40] I'd say so. I'd say a lot of people want to take our product home and make stuff with it, and that's where the plane really can like sing. You can fold it into eggs, make a cheesecake. More traditional Hungarian recipes would be more like a strudel or a dumpling stuffed with this stuff, but the kind of grab and go format, a lot of folks kind of want a little flavor. They don't just want the plain. And so we see kind of the two being right next to each other does do a lot of kind of unspoken education, but it also means that we're capturing a wider array of consumers. Um, and it's just the beginning, like, because we are cottage cream and we are that fresh cheese, it means we can go kind of in so many different ways with flavors. Like I can tease a few on the call today, but I would love to even do like a coffee flavor which is almost reminiscent of like a tiramisu because we do have that cottage cream base. Savories is something that's super interesting to me and it's something that is very common in like in that ready to eat format on shelves in both Germany and Hungary, like a paprika dip or stuff like that. So there's a lot of kind of ways to take. The brand and kind of use the base as kind of this powerhouse to go elsewhere, but we did really kind of want to start with things that were easy to wrap your head around just as you said, things that kind of help with that education burden, even if we're not in front of the shelf to kind of answer questions, just kind of those really kind of basic flavors that everyone loves. There's a reason why every kind of dairy brand starts with vanilla. It's that number one skew and kind of invites folks that have a little bit more of that sweet tooth to enter into the dairy case.

Ray Latif [24:05] Yeah, I think vanilla is a good call. Better than, say, perhaps beet flavor, which I don't know if they have a beet flavored uh uh churro in, in, uh, in Hungary or not, but uh it's probably a less familiar, a less familiar flavor to American consumers, at least in this category.

Speaker 2 [24:19] Yeah, maybe not in Hungary. I think if you went a little bit more east, you'd maybe see some beet flavor. I'd have to look back, and it's a question I'd like to float back to Bessy. Like when you think about flavors and formats coming down the pipe, we kind of stuck with the classics, but as we kind of grow, there's the urge in me to kind of embrace some Hungarian flavors, but you don't want to move away from the fact that we are in a US environment and like that might scare some people. It might kind of Make people walk away from the case. Yes, it would be sitting next to vanilla, yes, it'd be sitting next to a plane, so there are other opportunities for like people to jump in. But in my head I'm like, oh my God, there's so many desserts and flavors that I don't get in the US and now that It's my decision at the end of the day to kind of usher in these new flavors. Do I get selfish with it and bring in some, like currant or kind of some funkier poppy seed, like things that I just like, jump off the plane in Hungary and go straight into the grocery aisle for because I miss them, or do I really kind of temper myself and lean into that more American palette, or is it something in the middle? Like, these are things that we kind of think about when we're kind of going around the table on innovation and and trying to think about what's next.

Speaker 3 [25:25] Yeah, I mean, I think it's a really fair question and kind of boils down to what kind of brand do you want to be. Like speaking for Lane, there were two paths, right? Like you can do really authentic game and just for us that would just be plain, and maybe you could do some sort of a zaatar element of it. And I like the brand that we really want to build is something that is like creative, open, and lowers the barrier of entry of what Labne is. Like, I, as I think like the Labne lady of my business, I really don't care if people know what Labne is, where is it from, as long as they give it a try. And that's one thing that is like very open in the brand and the aura that we try to build, like we just want to make it fun. No pressure, no knowledge needed, just curiosity. And I have, like, the reason why I'm really excited to build this business in New York is like I think the New York's dynamic and energy is very much that. It's a very tort culture city. Everyone is kind of like an immigrant coming from somewhere else. There is this energy of tort culture pollination of the flavor creations that what people want to create better than the creativity around. It, so all the flavor based stuff we do is actually kind of trying to speak into that like hot honey is something that I literally came up in this kitchen over here through like, like buying Mike's hot honey. I'm like these would be so good and then went back to Turkey and find the pine honey that I grew up with and the chili flakes from Urfa region and really had. Take of sourcing and that was, or for the lack of a better term, or authentic storytelling, like it's the honey that I really love, you can't find it anywhere, like people don't know what pine honey is mostly. So that's how we're trying to find a middle ground, but I've tried to base the curiosity and openness element of within our brand that much, so that's why we're going to go with, I think anything that's creative, like I would be excited to do a very random flavor. Uh, but obviously the operational element of it is going to be really challenging, uh, to be that crazy about the flavor, so we're trying to balance it both.

Ray Latif [27:26] It, it's a tough call when you are trying to introduce a new product, a new flavor. You've got to test a lot and you've got to make sure that uh it is appreciated by a broad set of consumers, but at the end of the day, it definitely helps to increase the number of SKUs that you have on the shelf. Having that brand block will go a long way to getting people aware of what you're doing. But first, of course, you got to get in the retail store. I, I want to go back to retail just for a sec. Nicole, you recently won Fairway's new Fairway Find competition. What have you learned from convincing or learned about convincing retail buyers that a product without an established category in the US deserves shelf space? And in some ways, do you feel like you're creating a new category?

Speaker 2 [28:11] We always think like that's core to Ateca is we're opening up this new category that doesn't exist, but we are somewhat gaining trial from a consumer perspective as well as a retail perspective because of the success of cottage cheese, right? So we're opening up a new category, but we do have to sit in an existing shelf case if that makes sense. So We are constantly kind of back and forth between how much we anchor on cottage cheese and how much we kind of move away and really kind of pound the table that this is a brand new product, right, because the success of the category has really kind of created a space for us. Rising tides do raise all ships in this case, and so I think retailers know that they see the numbers in their categories. That's kind of Inviting them to speak with us in the first place, getting us that pitch slam invitation in the first place, and what we have to do is really convince them, when they taste it, that it's as good, if not better, than their leading kind of cottage cheese to use in terms of experience, in terms of flavor, in terms of nutrition panel and ingredients, but then also that brand story that we'll tell and kind of where we're going to partner with them on that education. It is a question we get from retailers, like how do we kind of bring people in that have never heard about this before, and that's where we as a founding team kind of say like we will partner with you on promo, we'll create those shelf talkers, we'll do demos where available. Obviously as we get bigger and we're in new markets, things that Eli kind of mentioned like you can't, once you've kind of burst out of your home market bubble, those resources become a little bit more constrained just in terms of being able to have boots on the ground, and that's where you kind of lean on perhaps social media or third party. Demo teams or promo where it is possible, but I do kind of want to kind of compliment our retail partners. I think a huge part of our strategy in opening up new markets and in kind of gaining trial outside of my immediate kind of reach here in New York has been by leaning on kind of community creators. So Central Market took us to Texas and we kind of just went there for demos, but Even if I wasn't there for demos, there was a lot of confidence in Central Market. They have foodies on the floor introducing customers to new products. They really do a beautiful job kind of creating stores that invite the curious, invite kind of the folks that want to take something new home, or maybe willing to spend a little bit more to have better for you ingredients and really cool brands on their table, and we are kind of always looking for who is that central market elsewhere, right? So. We'll be opening the Midwest with fresh time, so much confidence in that team to really create that community, to create that kind of buying experience where the customer's guard does come down because they trust the assortment that these buyers are bringing in. Same can be said for kind of our West Coast expansions. We're working with like Berkeley Bull to open up the West Coast, which has a cult-like following if you've ever been to the Bay Area, Town and Country Seattle. The list goes on, and the reason I want to call them out is because these buyers are special to me because they get it and I can kind of trust in them to really create an assortment even if our price is maybe a little bit higher than the other items on the shelf. I know that like just by being in these retail environments we get a better chance at folks kind of willing to take a risk on us because these folks have for decades created an environment that communities kind of rally behind, right? So that's been a core part of our strategy. the natural channel will exhaust itself at some point, and you have to go for like the bigger kind of retailers if you want to continue to grow, and we're crossing that bridge kind of sooner than I ever anticipated, which is a great thing. But a really big reason why we are here today is because we've we've found those communities and really enjoyed working with them. So yeah, that's a big part of trial too. It's just getting the right retailer to truly believe in you and to help you along the way.

Ray Latif [31:50] Absolutely. If you have a good relationship with a retail buyer, it can make all the difference, and it can make a big difference, I would think, in helping decide where your product best sits on sits on shelf. Merchandizing is not. The easiest science or part of this CPG industry that it should be or it could be because the retailer ultimately decides where your product is going to live on the shelf, but Ilay, have you had any influence on where BEZI best sits? It could be next to hummus, it could be next to other dairy products, and you know how much does shelf placement actually affect Whether shoppers understand what they're buying.

Speaker 3 [32:37] Absolutely, we have, I would say like all the control because we choose to go very slow. So when we launched, we did like a shelf test at Fairway actually. They were one of our first retailers, and BEZI sells twice more when it's put on a hummus aisle than a dairy aisle. And the product in terms of this use case needs to be in the dip aisle next to the hummus. So after that learning, we're just at hummus. If you see BEZI mistakenly in a dairy aisle, that means that like, I tried, but I couldn't make it happen. But we are exclusively in a hummus next to hummus, next to zasiki, next to all these like wonderful dips that you want to host your like friends, because the product itself is, it's naturally high in protein. It's good for you. There's all these elements of it, but it's a decadent product. It is meant for hosting. It is meant for enjoying, so it kind of gives a very different message when it is next to, I would say, like a hummus or a spinach artichoke dip than next to a Philadelphia cream cheese, because that customer. It's not going to switch Philadelphia cream cheese, uh, from our learnings at least. Could BEZI be like that? Probably, I mean, yeah, it could be like spread on your toast and your bagel, but that would not be the best, I think, basis of how we can build the category. And right, we go very slow, so we're just in the regions that we dominate, and we're in all these stores, so we're in. Like Northeast and all of them right next to each other and that creates, I think, more of a, I would say presence as BEZI to be able to attend to those shows along with we're just in like SF like LA and those like little pockets. So that's how we're trying to like I would say hack as we're now building something completely from scratch.

Ray Latif [34:14] And the one thing we haven't necessarily talked about, I guess there's a few things, but the one really important thing that comes to my mind is how fast you both are growing, even though you are being patient about growth, the opportunities you have in front of you are hard to ignore. And Nicole, you had mentioned that high protein culture, dairy manufacturing is becoming crowded, making it difficult to secure production time. So how are you managing that problem as you continue to grow?

Speaker 2 [34:42] Well, that's a great question. It's definitely one we get from retailers because they need that kind of confidence when they bring in a new product that we're not going to immediately hit them with out of stocks and empty shelves. But I think that's actually, it goes back to like what makes cottage cream different. We use completely different production lines than cottage cheese and what's kind of contributing to those shortages. What makes us smooth yet still high protein is. is a completely different facility than what makes the American curd cottage cheese. And so we've really kind of benefited from that difference. We're not seeing kind of competing lines with some of the bigger brands in the space. I think there's always this question of a brand. This is many years out of like, do you start to own your own production to take back control and that type of thing, but we're really not seeing. Pressures there whatsoever. I think it's more on us as a brand, um, because we do have this runway to really think about how do we really Like hone our operations model with such a great conman partner kind of behind us to really have that like excellence both in terms of how we work with distributors and retailers as well as our conman, right? So in the beginning when we were growing our MOQs were so big and I wasn't selling through product and we were donating kind of products right up until its expiry date to soup kitchens here in New York, but it was the cost of getting started. If I didn't make the product, I didn't get it out there, I had no shot at all. And now today we're at the point of selling through kind of that. At minimum order quantity and we're looking at, it's kind of exponential how you order products at my command, so you, the next batch would be double the size. We're using two bats instead of one and so we're kind of saying, do we have enough retailers kind of in our pipeline to time kind of bringing these on board that we have no waste going forward and that we can bring those online. So I'd say the Operating landscape and kind of that production landscape has actually really had more of an effect in terms of our sales pipeline and our planning and growing markets than perhaps even getting to market in the first place because what makes cottage cream so unique in the first place is really this moat in terms of keeping competition low because we just don't compete with the greater category and those and getting time with those same commands.

Ray Latif [36:54] And Nicole, I would assume your Coman is based here in the United States.

Speaker 2 [36:57] Yeah, so we took the approach of it's a fresh product with limited shelf life a little bit north of 2 months, and so that creates a lot of operational strain. Um, I don't know how BEZI does it importing it, but we took the approach of using local. American dairy kind of sourced within a very small 30 mile radius from our comman, but importing those cheese cultures. So our plane is just two ingredients grass-fed dairy and live active cultures. Those cultures are from Europe and kind of those. That flavor profile and kind of like what we need them to do from a dairy science perspective to create the authentic product. We are putting it in fresh PA dairy um here in the US to kind of maximize our shelf life and minimize kind of the exposure to imports and temperature variants on a ship, but, um, different products have kind of different risk areas, so I'd be so curious to hear about BEZI's decision to go the import route because it's definitely something we considered in the beginning.

Ray Latif [37:55] Yeah, well, my question was kind of a loaded question, but a loaded question that segues into how BEZI does indeed uh manufacture in Turkey and sell in the US. Yeah, so, you know, Ilay, how do you manage forecasting, production commitments, freight? And inventory when you're working across that distance.

Speaker 3 [38:15] So I'm lucky. Turkey's biggest chance manufacturers are my co-founders, and we started production first. So how we make BEZI, we honor our IP and honor our production. So effectively right now there would be no place that we can actually make BEZI in the US unless we decide to make that machine ourselves and bring that production. So because of that we were very clearly like restricted of doing this in Turkey, but also I really valued. Getting where the product was like initially, like the whole area has a version of lobne, so there is some sort of romanticism that comes with that along with the operation. And because of the dairy tech behind our company, it is 240 days refrigerator shelf life landed in New Jersey. And again, this dairy tech and this production would not be available anywhere in the US unless we decide to produce it one day. So with all of those, it kind of made sense to bring it. I was also very lucky that my co-founders have been sending their ethnic cheeses here for the last 10 years. So what started as like one pallet or two pallets within their ship now is becoming about like 70 to 80% of their containers every month. We were able to like scale them, make it by process in the way that it actually creates a continuous fresh product coming into New Jersey, which I think we're very like it was some time since we like was able to set this operation up, but I feel like now we feel very confident that this is a way that we can actually continue building our business. But also, Ray, I say no a lot. I don't go outside of my region. I'm not at UNFI. I'm not at Kahi. All of these great retailers that we're in, we work with smaller distributors or we work direct or we run our distribution level, so. At the back of, I think BEZI is a very strong operational decisions that we take, and we're also bootstrapped. So doing all of those things, I think made us come up with really clear decisions. So we try to go with, like this year for us in like moving towards 2nd year was And we were like Dippers is everything we're going to launch Dippers in these two retailers and that's it, and we didn't apply anywhere else. And that's the approach that we try to do every year to help with the forecasting and we have a lot of AI models in the background of BEZI to see how it's working like we track our shelf sales in both Whole Foods and Target every week. Um, that actually helps to create some of those things, but I think it starts with a very clear operational discipline of knowing what to say no, which is a lot of no's and very little yeses at this point of the business. It just has to be that way.

Ray Latif [40:48] Know what you're getting into as much as you can, uh, and this business will definitely punish you for mistakes. And just quickly, I'd love to, maybe folks wouldn't love to hear this because it's going to sound terrible, but, you know, when you are dealing with perishable products, what is the number one challenge that founders should watch out for? Nicole, let's start with you.

Speaker 2 [41:10] This is hitting home because we had a hiccup last week, so we're still kind of feeling the the battle scars of it, but perishable, I think, is, you don't know until it's too late, like what kind of extreme situations your product can find itself in, um. We had a misspick, for example, where someone misread a unit count as a case count, so instead of 17 cases going out, we had like over 100 going out, and so that had to come back home and be re-picked and then re-put on and then for that kind of process to happen, you're making a lot of phone calls. My team is up at 1 a.m. kind of making calls because that distribution center has hours that are one. 1 a.m. to 6 a.m. or something crazy. So it was just like the, the world of freight and 3PLs and and manufacturing was not kind of one that I was in prior, and so you kind of have to adjust and That's, that was just the beginning for us, we had a truck that I've since learned was dual temperature, so they have a refrigerated section as well as a freezer section. Uh, she's, she's not, she's shaking her head, she knows, she knows where this is going, which means that one of our pallets, because it was only one of our skews, was perhaps too cold, and our products can be frozen and nice and slowly thawed and be fine. But if you subject Atea to torture, which is freestyle, freestyle, free shaw, she starts to get A texture that looks akin to the American cottage cheese, and that's just complete product abuse. And so when you kind of have a distributor that is perhaps not putting in the right spot in the truck or if the truck is just not having that insulation between the two zones or it's left on the sidewalk in 80 degree heat because you're going to the south, like you don't know what's happening when you're not there. There's a lot of trust that we've put. In our freight providers or distributors or even the retailer once it's dropped off. And so perishability, I think, has been the biggest lesson in just taking a deep breath and figuring it out because you do have to relinquish control if you do want it to grow, and there's not a whole lot we can do. I think you can take the approach of Bezi and just have these like concentric circles and grow and really kind of hone in your supply chain and kind of Controlled way we kind of took the approach of working with one distributor first and figuring out those kinks, even if it was going to different markets. It was kind of controlled to this one ecosystem, if you will, but mistakes happen and so you kind of have to get ready for like no one got sick. This was not perishability in terms of the product was unsafe to eat. It just meant that that texture that is so. Much a part of the Etelka story and so much of what differentiates our brand was kind of messed with because of the cold chain being broken. And so those are things that you have to kind of navigate as they come. It's not much we can do to prevent them from happening in the first place, and you just hope that partners are there to kind of rectify the damage when it does happen. But I think every business has its Achilles' heel. Perishability, I think just is one that's just really obvious to all parties involved, whether it's the customer, the retailer, the brand, the distributor. It's just something you kind of have to give a little bit more attention and a little bit more um coddling to because the product is, is delicate, and that's what makes it clean and good for you. It's because it's these two ingredients that that need care. We're not putting in stabilizers or things that are shelf stable for good reason, and so it's, it's always a balancing act.

Speaker 3 [44:28] I mean, I had that happen to us, by the way, since people don't know what labne is and we can't be frozen because labne has like a good amount of whole milk fat in it. So when you freeze that, it will become like an ice cream freeze, and that happened to one of our retailers. That we were seeing that region as a test, like the whole Midwest, Ohio region was a test for us because we were like, OK, how does the tub perform? Like how does this situation perform? It was completely frozen because people don't know what labne is. Like you wouldn't necessarily put ice cream in an ambient shelf, but lobney, you have no idea. So, That's why it was frozen and it was like very curdy and it was a terrible product. And one of our customers who really loves Bezi out there literally DM'ed me saying that, hey, this is a little weird. And that kind of like made us trace back because we don't have the velocities that we have in New York. Like in New York, I would learn about this in a minute, or I would see it in a minute, but out there, I'm not there. And also we don't have that many customers. There's a new region for us. Um, that kind of traced into this like months of freezing problems. Like months it's been sold frozen, half thawed Bezi, which was terrible, but these things I think do happen but also I think great, what I would also say like perishable in a new product like we found our product next to refrigerated dough. Like who would buy us snacks to refrigerated though, like those things like do you have like refrigerated people feel like, oh, I squeeze it in here. I think those things always happen. My way of, I think, dealing with that as like a small business is I love concentric circles. I love domination. I also love control. I like run my own warehouse. I built my own apps. Everything needs to go to a photograph. Like I see everything and everything is reported to me through a series of basic custom apps that I built. This came from, I would. we moved to our first or 2nd year, we had a lot of like issues. Like it seems easy that I'm bringing it from Turkey, but if there's an issue, which we had a really big issue last year, thank God we didn't have it like impact our biggest retailers, but it impacted everyone else, and that started me being really obsessed with this whole perishability and this whole problem. So my reaction of it was like now everything on Bezi lives on an app. We have a team that does those things and raise certain flags, and I have pictures and I look at everything, which kind of helped us with our Target's first pick up because Target was like, well, we didn't receive this, and obviously they're fantastic partners, these things do happen, but we were able to go look at a picture and be like, this date, here we go, bill of lading. Automatically signed and that was how I felt was beyond their tenure as a two year old brand, but it was something that I had to do as perishable, going into big retailers like Target and Whole Foods, like I had no other chance. Um, so that's sort of perishable scary story in a nutshell and how we're trying to come on the other side of it.

Speaker 2 [47:23] No, I always said I was grateful for the mistake now. Like it was our first time leaving New York. I was there doing demos because I was so excited to like be in a different state, and I pulled it off the shelf and I found it, and I turned around and Vishnu, who's a stellar kind of member of our team, kind of go back and he's at MIT. I was like, can you build me like an AI inventory? Like I want when it leaves the facility into like I want to have this whole command. It's the same kind of thing. You just become obsessed with like the knowledge and having kind of control, even though you don't run the truck yourself. So I'm very grateful for the lesson early actually. I'd much rather pop in when it's half a pallet going, um, going out of state than when it's 30 pounds. So subject to abuse. Yeah, exactly.

Speaker 3 [48:07] You could, you could learn in a big retailer on a shelf with someone influential. Like all of these things happen, but, um, it is tough. It's not like I think building, like I know beverage is also really tough. Obviously every pocket of the CPG has its own unique toughness, but perishable dairy, a new product, is, I think the trifecta of. All the bad things that can happen to you is within this trifecta, but it's, it's fine. It's fine.

Speaker 2 [48:32] Next time we come on this podcast, we'll have gray hair. Probably I

Speaker 3 [48:36] start having a few, unfortunately, but

Ray Latif [48:38] yeah. Well, going through the hard times is an aspect of building a business that seemingly every founder has gone through and talked about and The most successful businesses are ones that persevere no matter what and can make their mark on an industry because they brought something different, unique, exciting to a new category or created a category. And so oftentimes I'll hear from new brands as we are the new or we're the next this or we're the, we're the, we're the next ciggies, we're the next Lifeway, and to get there. It takes a lot of hard work, but what does it take specifically? What would it take specifically for Ilay, Nicole, to make that leap from being a new brand, a new type of product in the US to perhaps the next Cigggy or the next Lifeway?

Speaker 2 [49:39] Oh, there's so many, I think, things that could perhaps take us there. I don't really know what that road entails. It's obviously continuing to execute really well in those partners that I shouted out and are kind of opening up new markets and bringing in that next tranche of amazing partners, um, and kind of creating more opportunities for folks to pick up Etelka. I think it's obviously bringing in more of that brand block, having more flavors and more formats. own that shell to have that beautiful kind of kaleidoscope of Etelka on the shelf and a lot of opportunities for people to pick it up. I always said for me, like when I know I've made it is when cottage cream just becomes kind of part of the sentence of the dairy case, like when there's not questions around what it is, when there's just kind of an understanding of how it fits in, what occasion that a family would use it for in their own kitchen, and so when it becomes kind of part of I think that moment that skier had kind of pretty recently, and we probably all kind of remember when somebody maybe told you about sky for the first time and they described it as Icelandic yogurt, but now when you hear skier, you don't need that that modifier on it. You don't need to hear skier Icelandic yogurt, you just know what skier is. Like that's kind of the hope of what cottage cream would be, and that's kind of, I think that like I've made a moment when someone can say cottage cream and just stop or just Etelka and people. what it is and just stop. Um, and I think that's, that goes hand in hand with kind of, again, why Bezi and Etelka are on the same podcast because we are bringing in these kind of different products and we're taking on this educational burden, but hopes are that kind of we become successful enough and people take a chance enough and they word of mouth, share it with their friends enough that one day, um, it's just an accepted fact that cottage cream exists in your fridge.

Ray Latif [51:19] Yeah, absolutely. Lifeway is a little bit more known in the US among American consumers, but same question for you, Ilay, how does Bezi take that leap from early stage to emerging to mainstream to, you know, universal brand sold across the United States. And I know again, you've talked about being patient, being thoughtful about growth, but how does that path or what do you need for that path to actually take place?

Speaker 3 [51:47] I think we're lucky to have a product that when it's sampled it becomes viral in that little grocery store hitting a tremendous amount of velocities like the numbers are there. So I think our biggest next step, obviously like I think different than Nicole, I have a bit of a tailwind on lobne, right? Middle Eastern products are hot. Barry is back. There are all these like when you go to restaurants in New York City, you will see Lobney and Dominion, and same goes with SF and same goes with LA. So we're very lucky to have a tailwind on the category, but for Bezi to come to the next stage, we need to be able to prove that we can reach trial at scale that enables velocity. I like there's all these romantic elements of, I think when it comes to any sort of a CPG business, we can go on and on. But at the end of the day, I think it's like a very cold numbers game. So for us to be able to hit those numbers and be confident that we can be a national brand, we need to prove that. So we have two regions. Um, one of the reasons that we wanted to test our present target was to actually test that theory and our buyers, I mean, shout out to Kelly Payton's amazing that has given us this chance, but understanding or limitations is It is going well and we're very excited about it. I think that's what will take Bezi and Labni to be the next thing is basically can we prove those with numbers in our regions.

Ray Latif [53:06] This has been a fantastic conversation. I've really loved every moment. I think our audience has as well. Nicole, Ilay, thank you so much for joining us on the CPG Operator podcast. Uh, I would love to see if we can make this happen again in a year or two. I, I, I don't expect you will have gray hairs, um, but I do expect that both of your brands will be at another level, and you are scaling at the pace that you hope and expect to or beyond.

Speaker 2 [53:35] We hope so. Thank you.

Speaker 3 [53:37] Amazing. Thank you.

Ray Latif [53:38] And thank you for everyone tuning in to this episode of the CPG Operator podcast. If you've enjoyed it, please subscribe on your favorite listening platform of choice and leave a review. Until next time, thanks so much for listening and watching.

Related Videos