New Beverage Showdown Finals - Round II

Tired of battling your kids over healthy eating or searching for truly natural, gut-friendly options? The Beverage Showdown Finals Round 2 brings you three innovative brands vying for the top spot! Witness Kif redefine "healthy soda" with all-natural kefir, Lucky Ox transport you with nostalgic Asian flavors, and Jubilee's revolutionize kids' milk with hidden fruits and veggies. Get ready for fresh ideas and bold pitches from the next wave of beverage pioneers!

Transcript

Note: Transcripts are automatically generated and may contain inaccuracies and spelling errors.

Speaker 1 [00:19] All right, we're on to round 2 of the finals for the new Beverage Showdown. We've got 3 more brands ready to present. We're gonna start right away with Caroline Brain from Kif. Come on up to the stage. Hello Good to see you. There's your clicker. Please keep an eye on your timer. There we go.

Caroline Brain [00:51] All right, hi everyone. My name is Caroline Brain and I'm the founder of KI. At KI we brew the only truly all-natural gut healthy soda on the market today. Now, if you're saying to yourself, what does all natural and soda belong in the same sentence, well, let me tell you about an ancient beverage called Kiefer soda. That's essentially a cross between a kombucha and a healthy soda. Now, I first fell in love with this beverage after unfortunately going through my own gut health issues. I was searching within the world of fermentation, frankly frustrated by how unapproachable most probiotic products were, until I found a light and bubbly beverage that did wonders for my gut health called Kiefer soda. I started brewing it. I started selling it at farmers' markets, and I quickly realized that I wasn't alone in my gut health issues because 2 out of every 3 Americans report experiencing gut health issues on a weekly basis, and I wasn't alone in craving a natural probiotic solution that actually fit into my daily diet. Key for soda was my answer. Now like kombucha, kefir soda is naturally potent in probiotics, thanks to its natural fermentation process, yet has a much lighter, less vinegary taste profile, lending itself to also be akin to a healthy soda. Many people are quick to categorize KI as a soda, but also quick to recognize that it doesn't have that artificial taste that most sodas do, and they're correct. KI is 100% natural thanks to its clean label ingredients and natural fermentation process. Now Kiefer soda combines the best of both of these worlds, combining the high functionality of kombucha with the high taste approachability of a healthy soda, lending itself to an even more massive market opportunity than either one. And at Kif we are going after this grand opportunity by brewing a uniquely delicious beverage that is highly efficacious for gut health thanks to having over 10 unique probiotic strains per can, over 12 billion living cultures, double that of what your standard kombucha, and yet extremely low in sugar, under 6 g per can. Keep Intentionally brewed to be subtly sweet with no caffeine and with no artificial sweeteners or artificial anything, it's the no-brainer, go to natural answer for anyone looking for a gut-loving sip, but especially for the urban power woman. With ambitious working women who value health, yet convenience in mind, we've developed this product, and they're leading the charge in our growth. With just under 2 years in retail, we're working with over 100 independent retailers and over 6 natural grocery chains. Now I can't tell you who, but we're finalizing the details with one of the largest natural grocers in the country for a phased national rollout. They're exciting about not just pioneering a new exciting emerging category, but a brand that's not afraid to evolve. KI as Nature Soda as you see it here today, is our new refreshed brand image just launched on June 1st. Previously marketed as a key for water, we've decided to strategically reposition the product to better communicate our core value to our core consumer. Developed during the premier CPG accelerator SKU with an all-star team of mentors, we've decided to strategically reposition the product as the truly only all-natural, top to bottom, gut healthy soda on the market today. Cheers.

Speaker 1 [04:58] Excellent work. If you just pull up to that X right there. Well done. Uh, John, we heard a lot about how great the taste of Kif is, but what do you think? Yeah,

Speaker 3 [05:08] I think the, the taste of the liquid is really nice. Uh, I mean, honestly, I could fill up, I don't know, 10 minutes with feedback on this. Um, you know, I think there's a lot to like about this. I think, you know, the, the evolution of the brand so far, like, You know, you're kind of figuring out, I think what other brands that have tried to go into this space, like, have discovered, which is like, you know, kind of figuring out how to straddle the line of being like fun, modern, delicious, and, you know, keeping the healthfulness of it in the conversation, but not like smashed into your face. Um, and I think, you know, on your pitch, there's maybe a little too much of like the We're more efficacious, like the reason that like poppy and lollipop work isn't because of like the healthfulness or chance thereof. It's the modern, the fun, unique flavors, and I think, you know, you have something here that could almost be an elevated version of that. It's just kind of like keeping that the gut health stuff, which like, yeah, everyone has, you know, knows that that's an issue, but we also don't really want to think about it when we go to the beverage cooler, you know, but again, I think, you know, the step you've taken is great. Really like the liquid. So it's work. Thank you,

Speaker 1 [06:22] Dan. Caroline talked about the market opportunity, huge market opportunity for a brand like KI. What are your thoughts? Yep, um, I guess the question I have is, um. Um, the difference between kiefer and probiotics and like what, what, what do you see as the distinctive difference, um, or what's the additive, so is it probiotics plus kefir, um, or is it kiefer plus probiotics? So in other words, like you've called out kiefer as, as, um, a, a way to differentiate it versus others, um, but I think it's well known, like the, the kind of the well-known addressable market is, is on probiotics and prebiotics. So you might say it's this plus this, and that gets you this. Um, how do you think about that?

Caroline Brain [07:00] Yeah, so the, the probiotics come from the kefir culture, which is used to ferment the product, but as you're alluding to, it's quite confusing. Kefir is known to be a milk product. There's a lot of confusion with is this a non-dairy version. And people don't get it, so that's one of the reasons why we repositioned the product more as a natural gut healthy soda to kind of diffuse all of that confusion.

Speaker 1 [07:25] Very good. I think, I think that works really well on this idea of the addressable market around urban power women and this notion of Potentially being even more edgy than some of the existing probiotic prebiotic sodas that are out there that are out there today and getting into that niche and then expanding from there, I think smart. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, yeah, yeah, Charlie Kif is about to enter a major natural retail chain. I don't know if it's Whole Foods or not, but, um, you know, I guess the big question is, can you scale beyond natural and you see that for KI. Yeah, yeah, I think um Yeah, I'm, I'm familiar with the product coming, coming into this meeting, and when I first saw it, I think I said they've managed to make Kiefer cool, which is really hard to do, and so I, I was impressed on the onset from the first time. I I think the challenge going forward is the education piece, so. A surprising amount of people probably don't know what keefer is like we, we're all always drinking our own bathwater around here and we know everything about every beverage ever, but, uh, teaching the customer how this is going to taste good in the soda format is, is a bit of an uphill battle, but I love the liquid. I think. It's nice to have something out of, out of the sphere of like high sweetness, and it definitely tastes efficacious, so. Awesome, thank you. Yeah, and Paula, do you, uh, agree with Charlie about a Kif making Kiefer cool, fun?

Speaker 4 [09:02] I think this is gonna be really hard to just sell itself on the shelf. There's a lot of questions, uh, Kiefer, the, the, the whole thing. However, if I'm you, I would spend all my time and energy, energy marketing this. I love that you said this is for the urban power woman. Um, I kind of want to see this in my feed as, hey, if you really want to make it, this is what you need. You need gut health. It's going to help your skin. Like I would put all my time and energy into getting influencers and getting this word out and the education piece, which is what you were talking about. I don't think it's just going to. Sell itself, um, on the shelf. So I, I, I would focus a lot of time and energy getting the right influencers and getting the word out on Instagram or TikTok made me buy it. Um. I could get roped into this very easily if you had the right message out there.

Speaker 1 [09:59] Awesome, thank you. There you go. Very well done. Thank you so much. We'll do this and this. Thank you. All right. Up next, we have the founders of Lucky Ox, Kyle Nguyen and Fein Hee. Come on up. Nobody's running to the stage like uh Jason did yesterday. So, oh, Sean, excuse me, good to see you from California. Good to see you. Uh, grab any of the microphones. You're quicker and please keep an eye on your timer, OK.

Speaker 5 [10:43] How's it going, everyone? I'm Fein Hee, co-founder and chief of door to door sales for the Lucky Ox. Hey everybody, I'm Colin Nguyen, and as the accounts call me, I'm the little one. Our brand honors Asian-American culture and the hardworking immigrants who shaped it. Growing up, I had a really hard time accepting my culture because I used to get bullied for bringing dumplings to class and um it hurt because I felt like a diss to my mom and the restaurant she worked in 7 days a week just to make ends meet for our family. But here we are, it's 2025, and now there's a massive appetite for Asian culture and flavors. That's why we started the Lucky Ox to elevate the nostalgic Asian flavors we grew up with and, most importantly, doing so in a way that highlights our cultural roots. So it looks like we're the only non-functional beverage in this entire pitch. And believe it or not, there's no AI in our beverage. What makes us different is that you probably haven't seen any of our flavors outside of an authentic Asian restaurant, like the one my mom works in. So we have 3 very distinct products. The Vietnamese lemonade sparkler is a unique salty lemonade called Chenmy, which you can really only find in a hole in the wall pho shop or a grandma's uh kitchen. Our matcha lemonade is our way of bringing a bright and refreshing take on matcha. Most matcha products on shelves are lattes, which are really just a coffee substitute. Um, but we're also proud to be one of the few, uh, ready to drink products that actually uses ceremonial grade matcha. Our Pandan coconut sparkler is our way of bringing the spotlight to Pandan, the vanilla of Southeast Asia. If you've had Southeast Asian desserts before, then you probably know about this flavor. The New York Times calls it the next big global flavor of 2025, and it's a classic we grew up with, but you really can't find it on grocery store shelves anywhere, and we want to be the first ones to bring it to the mass market and give it the attention that it deserves. We've been told that our flavors are really innovative in CPG and we're just happy that there's been just so much enthusiasm behind our flavors, and I'm just excited that I don't get bullied anymore for sharing these Asian flavors. And we really deeply connect to our consumers because you're either experiencing a new flavor or you're reconnecting with a nostalgic one. So we built this business with the same hustle and frugality that our immigrant parents instilled in us. You know, yesterday from our story about going door to door delivering cases on the subway. So we recently reached our 200 count milestone, distinct mix of retail on-prem just because of the versatility of our drink, whether it's in cocktails, dinner pairings, you name it. We have our account base and fandom in New York, but starting this summer we're laying the Groundwork for scalable retail expansion. So the first part is not spreading ourselves too thin geographically. Before manning our managing retail chain relationships, we need to understand where we perform well, both which set in the coolers and which types of account. We understand that we're a premium beverage for $4 in New York City, but we don't yet know what's the best price for Velocity as we expand to different regions like, like Boston or, or the mid-Atlantic. Right, so that's crucial before we get too deep into our rollout. We have the advantage of being really unique, but we also have the burden of not having clearly defined markets and comparisons. So we want to be efficient about where we deploy our capital to avoid expensive buybacks. We have great community connections, but we're just learning about how these connections are low cost drivers of awareness and drive long-term velocity. So there's many logistical challenges to Glass, right? But something important here is understanding what percentage of premium customers are willing to pay for this experience. Uh, between Fly By Jing, Nguyen Coffee Supply, and Camino, we've seen Asian brands win at a premium price point. Um, and premium experiences tend to be more accessible to mainstream audiences. End of the day, we make drinks that taste great. We work hard to share our culture, and that's why it wasn't just luck.

Speaker 1 [14:51] Come up behind you, well done. Uh, hang on to this, the judges might have some questions for you, and you can pull up to that X. There you go. Uh, Dan, let's start with you. We heard quite a bit about Lucky Oaks its origins, what it's all about, but when you saw the bottle in the sampling room, did, did you get it? I didn't, but that doesn't mean it doesn't work. It just means I didn't get it. And so I think that the piece that I, I didn't get is, um, but what I, what I do get is that it's very differentiated, so it's in a, you know, it's in a. Uh, a beer bottle type, and, and, and that's the biggest question I think we have is like on the packaging itself. And so, um, I think it's a, it's a bottle that, that, that you'd be proud to hold um if I know what I'm going to hold. So I think that the piece that I would um just, just think about, the liquid's amazing. So Um, and it's really delicious and I love the backstory and I love the positioning of, of, of Lucky Ox. I think what, what you might want, and it's early, I think when I see like where you're at, I think it's early, but what you want to think about is, I think the pack itself and what it communicates and how it communicates and um. And, and how, how mainstream or narrow cast did you want to be? And so, you know, if you said, uh, you know, gonna be in, in particular gro particular grocery stores and specialty markets, then we kind of take you in one direction, but If you said, well, no, actually I want to kind of be in a number of different locations, I, I would, I would, I would take you in a, in a different direction, but I think um the, the concept is there, the, the piece around the package and the, and the, and the label itself, um, just some elevation and some refinement there. But thank you guys for sharing. Thank you, sir. Thank you, Charlie. We always talk about brands needing to fill a gap in the market, um, fill a hole in a particular category. You see Lucky Ox as as meaning that white space where it is. Yeah, yeah, I, I, well, first, the coconut is Incredible. I mean, it tastes like dessert in a glass, um, so I was really impressed. Um. And I'm, I'm wanting to try the matcha now, so that is a really intriguing proposition. Um, I think taste of place is always going to have a, a home and an opportunity to suc succeed if, if done well. Um, I think something you should spend a lot of time pondering is who is your customer. And I, I actually, I did get what you were putting down like from the moment I I I looked at the bottle. Tell me if I'm wrong, but it's someone who wants to Have an experience, a culinary experience in a beverage and sort of be transported someplace that they may not be able to, um, and so the first time I saw, I saw your bottle before this and I, I myself was intrigued. I was like I, I can't wait to try it. It, it's just not done yet. So you, you're not quite baked, like you're, you're going somewhere, you're not quite in your final state yet, but I, I see where you're headed, uh, I just need some edits, but it's overall exciting. Paula, I asked one of the judges yesterday about the amber bottle, um, as a format for these types of products. Also, the use of sparkler as a descriptor. What are your thoughts?

Speaker 4 [18:12] Well, uh, until I tasted it, I didn't know that I needed to drink this. Um, the flavors are amazing. I think it, it, this could be in any container. It's just, uh, I don't think people will go to the store and pick this up unless they know about it, right? So if I, I would be sampling this all day long and putting it in people's hands, because again, like I didn't know that I needed to have this flavor. In my mouth until I, it's just so foreign, right? So it's sampling, it's sampling, it's sampling. It's almost like one of these, uh, if you know, you know kind of beverages, right? So, um, you can create a whole like viral movement around it just putting it in the right people's hands. That's, that's what I would say. But because the flavors are so different, I wouldn't, I, I wouldn't necessarily know I needed it until you sampled, sampled it with me.

Speaker 1 [19:10] All right, it's not just a cocktail, it's what you get. Last word, John Craven. Yeah, I mean,

Speaker 3 [19:14] I, I think the only thing, uh, I maybe add on to what Paula said is I feel like you've got pretty bold and unique liquid, and I feel like the brand is kind of like more low-key subtle. And you know, I see even like your t-shirts, it's like that feels more bold than like the label, and I, I wish that like label like was bold, you know, to match the liquid, um, and the liquid tackle what they said, I mean, really, really great liquid.

Speaker 1 [19:43] All right, great feedback, great presentation. Well done, guys. Thank you. Good job. Well done. All right. Our final presenter for the New Beverage Showdown, that's Ashley Wildman, who is the founder of Jubilee. Come on up. I like the fact that you jogged up here. Well done. Take notes. Yeah, talk about it. Clicker timer, please keep an eye on it. Thank

Speaker 6 [20:13] you. Excellent. Good to see you guys all again. My name is Ashley Waldman. I'm the founder of Jubilees. For those of you who weren't here yesterday, we're going to do a little survey again. Please raise your hand if you are a parent. Keep your hand raised if you agree with the statement. Fighting with your kids to eat healthy sucks. No surprises. Most people kept their hands up. Congratulations, you are part of the 70% of parents that struggle with this every single day. I'm a mother of two very young kids, 3 years old and 5 years old. My oldest daughter is autistic, and so this is a part of our daily lives. It's all day, it's every day. I created my brand Jubilees to provide some relief. It is a clean, functional flavored milk with a secret. It is the only flavored milk that is sweetened exclusively with fruit and vegetables. This is such a novel innovation. I'm actually in the process of converting a patent for this. 0 g of added sugar. It also has 8 g. Of natural protein or 60% of your kids' daily need depending on their age. I say natural very intentionally. There's no like weird protein systems or protein isolates. It is just natural in the milk. It's also much more nutritious than a conventional flavored milk. We added an Acerola cherry extract and also an algae-based vitamin D. So I developed my product a little differently than a lot of people in CPG. A lot of people start with a solution. It's their mom's cookie recipe or they love pizza and then try to fit it into market afterwards. I did it in the completely opposite way. I come from technology and I've spent my career building other people's business. most recently with Google building an AI safety system from scratch to 70 people, complex algorithms, and UIs, and with that kind of stakes you have to start small. We use something called agile, which basically just means starting with a problem, developing an NVP, getting user feedback. iterating user feedback iterating and that's exactly how I started so it didn't even start as a flavored milk. It didn't even start as something called Jubilees, but I collected more than 6000 survey responses and 100+ hours of consumer interviews over 3 years before I manufactured anything at scale. At one point I thought vegetables on the package was a good idea. Turns out that is a huge turn off to children. Weird. How did I not see that? I don't know. Let me give you an example. So this is the market known as flavored milk. One place I started was just asking parents generally if you could wave a magic wand and invent the perfect kid's beverage. What would it look like? Low sugar, high vitamins. I looked at the market and said, What the H is going on here? And I decided to do both of those things. One of my favorite entrepreneurs is Walt Disney. One of, one of my favorite quotes is he said, Their mediocrity, their mediocrity is your opportunity. Another one of my favorite founders is Estee Lauder. She said, the best ideas glimmer in their simplicity. I saw this data and it glimmered to me. This is another example. So the dairy market, I wasn't even calling it a flavored milk. I was like, maybe it's protein, maybe it's a smoothie. But then I saw how massive flavored milk is. Just to put it into context, $57 billion that is 30 times the size of the ready to drink protein space. Slate is in that space. I think they're doing pretty well. So I saw this and was like, duh, it is a flavored milk. I also saw that there's tons of headroom when I'm talking to buyers and I'm saying, I don't just want to steal market from Horizon. That's no good to you. There's still plenty of room. I'm gonna keep going because we're almost out of time and I don't want to get gonged again. OK, so I've been here less than 4 months and I'm already driving velocities of 25 to 30 units per store. I won the uh Cahey's trend Finder campaign. I'm also part of their, um, Elevate accelerator program. I won the Beverage Forum's Brand to watch competition. I was featured in Fox News.

Speaker 1 [24:19] Damn it,

Speaker 6 [24:20] I got so close. Thank you.

Speaker 1 [24:25] Hang on to that. If you pull up to the X-ray here, as I've said before, the gong means gray on it though, yeah, but it's yours today. Uh, the gong means you did really well. Great job. Uh, Charlie, let's start with you. Uh, it's no secret kids' beverages are tough, but can jubilees be that exception? Yeah, yeah, I mean, I think that you nailed it when you said that you're not just going to try to steal shares from this other brand. The retailer is always going to think about incrementality, and that's not something that brands always consider when they're, they're presenting their offering. It's always like this tastes better than so and so and. It, it usually is, is not a winning approach, so you look as though you have captured a real white space opportunity that is just no one is playing in right now and, and I'm intrigued and, um, you know, I'm, I'm part of the millennial statistic of no kids, so I, I had

Speaker 6 [25:30] it right, you can have flavored milk

Speaker 1 [25:31] too, yeah, and I did today earlier back there. I liked it um it's very playful. The only other thing I was gonna call out is. You know, you're, you're, you're obviously going to appeal to a more natural health focused family when it comes to dairy. There's the opportunity just for a sourcing story around the dairy itself, like regenerative, or yeah, I mean there's, there's a lot of different ways to go, um, even, even if something as subtle as partnering with. With a really well-known Health Halo, you know, Happy Cows brand, there's a lot of different opportunities there. So yeah. Paula, we talked about this a little bit yesterday. Uh, kids' beverages, you've got to appeal to the parents as much as the kids. Do you see that for jubilees?

Speaker 4 [26:22] I think, um, excuse me, you mentioned that you did some testing and showing vegetables on there isn't a good idea. I've tasted your product. It's fantastic. And then being a mom myself, I want to put something in front of my kids so all the problems are being solved. I would push your packaging even further though to be fun for the kids, like. Anything that could push it to a place where they would be happy to hold it or interact with it in some way.

Speaker 6 [26:52] I had a mom talk to me about like color changing straws,

Speaker 4 [26:56] yeah, anything. It's kind of like, you know, kids really, you know this, there's a badge value to what they want to put in their mouth and if you're. Giving them something healthy if you can have a really fun unpack. I don't know if you're going to be sold in 4 packs. Like I would almost say like you put the information for the mom on a 4 pack on the outside, and then when you pull it out, it's like a happy face or something, something so ridiculous that your kid actually wants to hold it and interact with it and have fun on that level.

Speaker 6 [27:25] That's really great advice. One of my favorite brands is Bear Snacks. I don't know if you've seen those, but they have these little like play cards inside. Love that. I would love to do something like that. Thank you. Yeah,

Speaker 1 [27:34] John, what do you think of the approach of infusing vegetables, better for you ingredients into milk?

Speaker 3 [27:39] I mean, I think it, you know, certainly is an understandable, like, I don't know, functionality to add without adding, you know, some ingredient that might offend someone, um. You know, I think it's, it's interesting like I, I guess a couple of things I've wondered about are like, do you need more protein? You know, I saw you have parity with some products and are lower than others, not saying you should be the highest. Um, the other thing I wonder about is just the You know, the straw format versus using one of those like uh Dream cap things or whatever that might slightly extend the demographic for your product, uh, because I think that's, you know, another thing that just to state the obvious, like seems somewhat limiting of where it can go. But on the other hand, like, I totally respect that you're, you know, providing something very direct for like a specific demographic, so wouldn't want you to lose that either. Just maybe could you extend it a little bit? So

Speaker 6 [28:33] yeah, it's really good advice. Thank

Speaker 1 [28:34] you. Uh, Dan, last thoughts, but I'd also love to hear your take on the potential for flavored milk. Uh, Ashley outlined a real big opportunity. Do you see that as well? Yeah, for sure. I, I think, um, uh, what I loved about your presentation and then the product itself is, um. You, you, you know, you know, you should, you know, I'm gonna get going, uh, the, the, the founder evolution, um, which was from rise and shine at Jubilees, and so it just said you can continue to listen and plow, you know, um, you know, the, the, the work that you're seeing out in the marketplace, you know, into the product, which is really hard for a founder to wanna do to wanna pivot. So that's really cool. I think the, the biggest thing that I saw, um, because of the fruits and veggies and You know, as a, as a parent versus a kid, kind of looked at it and said, I, I do still feel like you're burying the lead, you know, like the, um, and that could go on point of sale, but oftentimes you're not going to get the point of sale for the vegetable and it doesn't mean like big veggie, but it does mean something. So I think this idea of like it needs to be outwardly sneaky almost like because you snuck those in, you know, for the kid, which is fun, but it's also fun for the parent, and so there's this piece of like. It's in the ingredient panel, um, you know, on the, on the side, uh, on the side of the, the box, but I think there's this piece that you wanna say it's like how can you make that a little sneakier and more fun around jubilees, and I think that kind of that turn of it, it's gonna be really, really helpful, and how you do it, I think is really important because you throw fruits and veggies out there, it's probably not gonna cut it. You've, you've already learned that. So

Speaker 6 [29:54] thank you. I agree. Thank you. Do you mind if I ask just one follow-up question like the Between the protein and the vegetables, like, are we pushing both of those? Are we pushing one? I just feel like protein is like such a hot thing now, but I don't want to just be like playing on a trend.

Speaker 1 [30:07] We are out of time. That my flashing. It's OK, but I'll give you, I'll give you 15 seconds. No, yeah, on protein, I don't, I actually don't know what to say in the kids category on. What what the relative importance of protein is, so I wouldn't be able to answer that question. I mean, I know protein's a hot trend for like for sure on adults, but on kids and whether parents want their kids to have that protein. I think the calorie count probably matters, you know what you're doing. So every gram of protein kind of adds a certain 7 calories per gram or so, but you know that's that's the piece I just watch out for. Yeah, outstanding. Well done. Thank you. I'm glad that Ashley asked that last question just because uh I do want to say that all of the finalists did such an amazing job today. There will be a winner, but everyone did such a good job, and I want to make sure that they get to speak with a lot of folks in this room, including some of the judges, to get more feedback because there's not, you know, 4 minutes, it's just not enough time. So, congratulations to all the finalists. We're going to be back here at 12:45 to announce the winner of the New Beveridge Showdown. You don't want to miss it, you're going to turn off the stage.

Related Videos